What are the operational costs of additional busses/drivers over a thirty year period vs the operations/maintenance of a light rail line? Trains and trams typ last 40 years or so. Busses quite a bit less. Would more busses and bus operators be needed to approximate the capacity of a light rail line?
There are a lot of interesting questions. I’m sure someone did the research / due diligence. Probably when applying for federal funding many years ago. We’ll have a Purple Line like it or not, and improved access to the Red Line from Bethesda Row. And yes, criminal activity may or may not increase in the area near the new portal. We’ll have to wait until 2028 though because of all the delays and cost overruns. We should’ve all been enjoying it (or regretting it) by now. I do hope the sound walls aren’t too high so the passengers can enjoy the scenic views of Chevy Chase and the golf course. |
It will be nice to use and it's going to be built. However, it was a terrible financial decision. Buses are much better from a financial perspective because it is less costly to expand or reduce capacity in response to demand. The metro will cost hundreds of millions a year regardless of whether anyone actually uses it. If they expand buses and demand is insufficient to justify expanded services they can cut operations (or modify bus routes) at a relatively minimal cost. The metro route is fixed, inflexible and more costly. |
Bethesda to the middle of UMD campus will be 35 min station to station. |
Correction, 35 min to the edge of campus on Adelphi Rd, 39 to the middle of campus. |
If true then there must be signal priority along University. Interesting. |
Not sure, you can see that the effective speed, which can be as high as 34 mph between CC and Lyttonsville, drops down to 13-19 mph on University. It then then slows down to a crawl (8 mph) on the UMD campus with students crossing all over... |
[twitter]
And how much time to get to Bethesda station from home? From a lot of Bethesda you can do that same trip from your house in 30 minutes. If your point is that someone will live in an apartment in downtown Bethesda, anyone that can afford that rent values their time and no one that values their time would waste it pointlessly on the Purple Line. |
DP here. People on the Metro subway often read the paper (on their phones) check email etc. All that is easier to do while commuting via train vs driving. And so long as it is safe, there are people who prefer to commute via train vs driving in traffic. Less stressful. Now if the train commute is much much longer than a car commute, that may negate the benefits. |
The Purple Line rolling stock will barely have any seats. |
Lots of seats with cushions are what attract commuters. That’s why Metro’s new trains are keeping the large number of perpendicular cushioned seats despite pushback from transit advocates. (Addressing the advocates’ concerns however, there will be some NYC style beach seats in the new trains.) It would be a shame if the new Purple Line light rail trams have few seats. |
The people who livei n apartments in downtown Bethesda are not the primary targeted demographics for the purple line. The purple line will be primarily for people who live in PG County, Takoma Park, Silver Spring, White Oak who have to travel to work over in the Bethesda area. People that can't afford to live in an apartment in downtown Bethesda, but who have to work in Montgomery County. These are people who have spent hours on busses or on the Metro to go down into the city and back out the other way, or people who have to negotiate with a family member for use of a shared car. Going the other way, it is for people who live in Montgomery county, but are going to school at UMD. This will get a ton of cars off of the overly congested Beltway and East-West Highway and get those roads less crowded for those who will still commute by car. |
Bordering? |
The Purple Line sadly may bring the criminal predators from PG and parts east to prey on Bethesda. |
If this is a concern, voting for politicians who are pro law and order and organizing things like neighborhood watch go a long way. Also, cameras. On homes and businesses. |
There are not enough jobs in Bethesda to justify this use case. The UMD will be a real beneficiary because the station is on campus. But when you look at travel times, the best case you can make is to consider that it will allow grad students to live in downtown Silver Spring and on the other side, lower level support workers living in PG County. |