How is admitting 150 algebra1 students to TJ class bottom to struggle with remedial math considered anything but opening door to fail? |
90% of the MIT, Caltech, and Ivy League kids took Algebra I in 8th grade a generation ago. I don't think this is the issue. I don't know what the criteria is of this US News report. I just think these kids who are at this level should have also done something else to deserve getting in beyond just doing well in classes. |
Why do some posters keep labeling the Algebra 1 students (taking geometry at TJ) as remedial. Algebra in 8th is still 1 year ahead of normal pacing. |
The math level isn't the issue, specifically. A generation ago, many very talented kids lacked access to Algebra I, even when they were 99th percentile+ kids. Currently in FCPS, no one lacks access. Every kid is given numerous years and paths for AAP or advanced math. They are given all of the tools they should need to qualify for Algebra in 7th, and the bar is not overwhelmingly high. The kids who don't qualify in FCPS simply aren't very good at math. This is doubly true for the LCPS kids taking Algebra in 8th. |
I'm not that poster, but they have a point in the context of TJ. TJ only accepts a small fraction of the FCPS kids, and it has a mission statement of providing an appropriate education for kids with needs well above their peers. It's hard to justify placing kids on a track that's barely above average into an elite magnet school where they will be comparatively behind the other kids. I'm not even opposed to Algebra I kids being admitted to TJ, providing that they demonstrate high aptitude in some other STEM arena. The current application process leaves no room for any kid to demonstrate any level of excellence. It instead assumes that kids who are somewhat above average in math and kids who are elite in math from the same SES level and at the same school are indistinguishable and equally in need of TJ. |
|
No one is assigning labels here. The information is based on facts regarding the remedial math assignments that freshmen are receiving. A significant number of the admitted "9th grade students (are) scoring below proficient on the initial Math Inventory," as reported by the TJ Principal. It doesn't seem like the TJ Principal is labeling anyone either; rather, they are addressing the "below proficient" algebra skills within the admitted class right upfront. If anything, the TJ Principal is clearly indicating that since the School Board removed the entrance math test, TJ Math teachers are now compelled to conduct basic math evaluation as soon as students enter into TJ. |
Given all the meddling the school board has done in the name of equity, I'm surprised it hasn't plummeted to 140th place! |
but that's fake news |
I'd expect it to be back to number 1 since they put an end to the test-buying which caused the drop |
Yes, I liked the good old days when you could just buy the test answers. Things were far more predictable. |
You are almost right! 31% of 550 is well over 150 algebra 1 students. The year before with old admission process, it was never more than 20+ algebra1 admits. "Compared to TJ Class of 2024, the proportion of students in Class of 2025 admitted with the minimal required math background of Algebra 1 in 8th grade increased sevenfold, from 4.5% to 31%" https://fcag.org/documents/TJ_Class_of_2025_analysis.pdf |
What is your source. The other point, you are talking about a generation ago. You are doing dis-service to the kids that their talent and hard work is not needed by this community. Dis-service to the country by ensuring we slip in innovation and competitiveness to other countries. The Equity warriors are taking community and country to a worst place. |
Kids in Algebra in 8th should not be bussed to a magnet STEM school. |
It’s pretty hilarious that Young Scholars carries more weight in the admission process than FCPS own AAP. |