Is Comma Lady and Nanny Deb the same person?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Is they?

I also noticed OP's grammatical error. How ironic that she thinks she knows anything. She's an ignorant bitter bully without a life. She should go back to that squabbling tribe of hers.

[Anonymous]

Who the hell cares,,,,,,,,,,,get a hobby!

[Anonymous]

I actually think most of what nannydeb says is sensible. At least she has a consistent point of view. You may disagree with it, but you cannot say she's incoherent or inconsistent. I don't think she's a troll, and I don't think she'd be hiding under different posting identities.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I actually think most of what nannydeb says is sensible. At least she has a consistent point of view. You may disagree with it, but you cannot say she's incoherent or inconsistent. I don't think she's a troll, and I don't think she'd be hiding under different posting identities.

All we know is she's a nanny. We don't even know if Deb is her real first name. I can't identify anyone who is incoherent or inconsistent. How would you indentify inconsistency? Probably lots of people have imperfect spelling/punctuation/grammar.

[Anonymous]

I disagree with some of NannyDeb's opinions, but they are always well written and rational. She generally uses commas properly. Comma lady uses them improperly, consistently breaking certain specific rules of punctuation that I won't bother naming.

Also, I don't recall reading any "MB needs psychiatric help" nonsense in NannyDeb's posts, whereas Comma Lady sprinkles them around freely. Comma lady also starts a lot of threads with sweeping, inflammatory one- or two- line statements. I haven't seen that from Nanny Deb.

I see no reason to think they are the same person.