Reply to What does Islam say about concubines?

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "What does Islam say about concubines?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]
Nope. There was no denigration. There was simply clarification to you that the scholars you refer to are from regions of the world where [b]tribal culture is still pervasive.[/b] Every Muslim organization condemned ISIS yet the beheadings continue. ISIS justifies itself and I am sure they can find scholars somewhere out there to support them. That doesn't make their actions legitimate. Stoning still exists for adultery and some Muslims will be quick to pull put some hadith. But it directly goes against the Quran which never mentions stoning. So of course there are those that have a harsher perspective but its[b] often not backed up by the Quran, which is the ONLY true word of Allah.[/b]

When you are trying to determine if a scholar is correct or if a hadith is correct the best thing you can do is look for validation in the Quran.   [/quote]
Most Muslim-majority countries qualify as "regions of the world where tribal culture is still pervasive." Does it mean you are single-handedly rejecting the totality of Muslim scholarship that came from Muslim-majority countries? Whatever, as I said, Islam did before Hamza Yusuf showed up!

Secondly, Jamal Badawi lives in Canada.  Yusuf Qaradawi heads the European Council on Fatwa and Research.  Is tribal culture pervasive in both Canada and Europe? Do they know about that?

Thirdly, you MUST know that your wholesale rejection of ahadith and the body of Shariah places you firmly outside of Islamic scholarly consensus on the subject of what acceptable sources are for interpreting Islam. Praying five times isn't in the Quran either, does it mean you reject that part as well?

But then again, if you're the poster who believes that somewhere in Saudi Arabia, locked up in a secret vault, there's a collection of the only authentic hadith in the world that hasn't yet been distributed to the world (why?), then we're venturing into a whole 'nother territory of crazy.  I mentioned that claim to my husband, and "crazy" were his exact words. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics