Reply to UVA McIntire or top 15 school?

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "UVA McIntire or top 15 school? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Why are people bringing up MBA?
That's something you would consider later after you have real careers.
[/quote]

I'm the business professor who brought it up, because OP was discussing choosing UVA/McIntire over "Top 15" schools without business majors.  Instead of basing four years of undergrad on an uncertain business career, you could choose the best undergrad school and then later get an M.B.A. and a "real career".

Historically, M.B.A.'s were rare and more technical, with many engineering and economics majors.  But the number of degrees has tripled since the 1980's, and the curriculum has been watered down.  Spreadsheets and statistics on personal computers were a big deal in the 1980's.  But high school students have laptops today.

As a professor, here is what is galling.  Some say M.B.A.'s are "quant", which is usually wrong.  Others say one-year masters are not quant, except for schools like Princeton.  But if you can get into a "Top 15" college, then you should be able to get into a top quant program later.  People are not discussing what you actually learn in the classroom to support a business or finance career.  This suggests a myopic thought that McIntire business "connections" will get you an entry job and career for life.  I would prefer the connections from Northwestern/Dartmouth/Brown/Cornell/Columbia, even without an business degree.  If you can't afford a fifth year for a masters degree, then in-state tuition at UVA merits consideration.

Your kid might not even like business.  Or, your kid can choose a different major and get a masters degree later.  Choose McIntire because you prefer UVA, not because it guarantees a business career for life.[/quote]

I think your mindset never evolved since 1970s.  
You get real and one of the best 'real career' with McIntire degreee as well as 
No need to invest more time and money in the MBA or Masters unless you have some special intestea or goal later after the 'real career'
You actully learn real stuff at the work.

Sure Econ or STEM at Northwestern/Dartmouth/Brown/Cornell/Columbia are great (one caveat is that Cornell Dyson is also 'Business Program' that you don't like)
They are just equally target schools just like the top business programs at UPenn Wharton, MIT Sloan, Berkeley Haas, Georgetown Mcdogh.
However in terms of UVA McIntire vs ECON Northwestern/Dartmouth/Brown/Cornell/Columbia, it's a valid opion, but still they are just different options.  
MBA has no place in this discussion.

You also contradict yourself.  You sounds like advocating to 'liberal art' education, but sounds like not a fan of the real liberal arts majors like history, anthropology, political science, etc. (execpt for econ).  Sure CS, Math, Physics, are part of 'liberal arts' but you specifically like STEM.  I agree with you on this LOL.
However, business degree at target schools are the next best thing if not equally the best thing.

Nlow in general you get BSBA for business program, but you speicalize in certain areas such as finance, accounting, marketing, management, etc.
I would stay away from areas like marketing or management too are too broad. 
Not everyone is STEM type, my recommendation is Accouintg, Finance, MIS, or Business analytics if in business program.
Of course nothing is guranteed.  McIntire is one of the biggest reasons to consider UVA beside of instate status.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics