Reply to ECNL vs GA

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "ECNL vs GA"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Again. There is no difference. There are ECNL teams who beat GA teams and there are GA teams who beat ECNL teams. A both are equally providing exposure. The key here is to focus on your own player and what they can do.[/quote]

There’s definitely a difference.[/quote]

If they both put the player in front of the same college coach then there is no difference. That is what matters to me as a parent. Now what teams are in each league and what players play in each league, I could care less. [/quote]

So there’s no difference between the leagues? Equal number of college commitments in number and quality?[/quote]

Please show us, tell us, share with us any non-FCV girl from GA who has got a P4 offer in the last two years since FCV fell apart in the DMC. I'll wait...[/quote]
Wow you really are broken record. Must be really fun to be around. For the thousandth time, most ECNL and GA players do not go P4, are not targeting P4 college coaches, and therefore that is not a factor for them. What matters is if the schools you are targeting are going to be there. If your daughter is targeting high academic mid-majors, small liberal arts schools, D3 (god forbid!), regional state schools, then depending on their grades and aspirations, GA might be just as good or in some cases a better option because they might get more playing time and stand out more. The point is it's individual and your stats like number of P4 players recruited has no relevance for most players.[/quote]
What broken record casually skips over is 90% of P4 commitments come from the same top 10% of clubs. What this means is if you're not playing for a club like San Diego Surf it doesn't matter if you're playing in the same league they play in. The clubs that get players into P4 colleges could choose to play in any league and still get players into P4 schools. This was proven when everyone switched over to DA. Ever wonder why the ECNL stats people stop at 2020?

For 99.9% of players playing in GA or ECNL doesn't matter. For the top .01% coaches from the top clubs will find, identify, and recuit them to play on their top teams.

ECNL stats guy just likes to ride the coat tails of successful clubs. Most likely his kid plays on a mid to lower level ECNL club. I know this because that's how the percentages of players works. Also, parents on top teams dont spend their time online fighting about leagues. [/quote]

You do realize all of the top clubs in the development Academy were clubs that had come over from ECNL? Development Academy had a short run and then most of those clubs returned to ECNL.[/quote]
Not all but yes many were.

And it just highlights what I was saying. Playing for an average GA or average ECNL club will generate roughly the same results. For most players.

If your kid is good it won't matter because they'll find their way to a top team.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics