Reply to Deciding whether to try for latin

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Deciding whether to try for latin"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I was pro-DCPS all through elementary school and up until April of the month we did the middle school charter lottery, got a spot at BASIS, and had a candid conversation with a DCPS middle school teacher who told me straight-up to take the BASIS spot because her DCPS did not meet the needs of advanced students. she wanted to, but the structure of the curriculum, her inabiity to fail students, her principal all kept her from adding enrichment and appropriate instruction for advanced students.

She was really unequivocal and I made my decision immediately after that conversation. She also said getting a seat at BASIS is like getting a prep school education for free, which I think it true about Latin as well. I'm very, very glad we took the spot.

[b]I'm sure I trash talked charters when my kids were young. But the middle school ecosystem in DC is very different than elementary. I recommend doing some research and allowing yourself some grace to change your mind.[/b] [/quote]

Truly appreciate this candor. The trash talking charters and "down with charters" mentality has created an environment in DC where politicians feel comfortable openly under-resourcing charters. It's not a little bit of money - it's estimated at $1,800 per student and that's money that a charter school doesn't have to improve teacher salaries, increase benefits, offer more athletics and clubs or fix sub-par facilities. Ask your charter school principal what they could do with that much more per kid. [/quote]

It's pretty shameful how the city systematically shortchanges charters. Enrollment in charter schools is growing way, way faster than at DCPS, and it won't be long before the majority of children in this city go to charter schools. [/quote]

If you look at the recent lottery data (take a look at the thread about it) you will see that this is decisively Not True.  Waitlists for charters are plummeting. [/quote]

In 1996, there were approximately 160 kids in charter schools in DC, and nearly 80,000 in DCPS.

Today, there are roughly 48,000 charter school kids and about 50,000 in DCPS.

One of these school systems is seeing explosive growth and the other is in the midst of a very steep decline. [/quote]

Oh FFS. You're playing with the numbers to hide what's really happening. Which is that both sectors have leveled off and are flat or growing at 1-2% annually. Yes there was a lot of charter growth twenty years ago. That time is gone. [/quote]

What's really happening is people are voting with their feet. Take whatever time period you want. Over the past decade, charters have been growing twice as fast as DCPS. [/quote]

Okay, how about the past two or three years? Tell us, how's the growth?[/quote]

Charters are still growing faster, especially in Wards 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6. The overall lead is smaller primarily because fewer DCPS kids in Wards 7 and 8 are dropping out of school. Congrats?[/quote]

Where are you getting your data? And are you including adult ed programs?

Just for example I compared OSSE enrollment spreadsheet totals of UPSFF students from the current school year and the 23-24 school year. Over that period DCPS is up 1.34% and charters are up 0.47%.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics