Reply to 43 Vehicle Thefts in DC in First 3 Days of 2024

Forum Index » Metropolitan DC Local Politics

Reply to "43 Vehicle Thefts in DC in First 3 Days of 2024"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]We need 20-30 year mandatory minimum sentences for any car theft. Period. [/quote]

The Supreme Court would disagree with you! Moreover, that is cruel & unusual punishment. We need more social services and campaign push for helping fathers parent. Many of the kids stealing probably don't have fathers in the home because the fathers are away in jail. More jail will not resolve the issue. [/quote]

I think you, respectfully, need to step back from your privileged position and take a look at how the crime impacts those with less resources then you if you think 20-30 years in prison is a ‘cruel and unusual’ punishment for stealing a car.

Imagine you are a poor single mother. Let’s say one day some kid steals the car you worked hard to afford. You now have no transportation, you cannot get to work, so you lose your job. You cannot fet your kids to school, so they get in trouble for absenteeism and ultimately expelled, and you can’t get to the grocery store, so you are forced to feed your kids what is available at the corner store, which leads to them getting obese and having to deal with the medical complications of that.

I hope you can see that stealing the car didn’t just steal this single mother’s physical item, but it was stealing her sole mode of transportation and he dignity. Sure, when your car is stolen, maybe you have the privilege to just laugh on the drive over to the Maserati dealership about how you wanted to buy a new car anyway, but for the vast majority of people, losing their car is a serious, often unrecoverable disaster.

So, tell me how 20-30 years in prison is ‘cruel and unusual’ punishment in this case? How is such a violent and evil crime not worth a punishment that matches its severity, and how do we tell the victims that such evil only justifies a slap on the wrist?[/quote]

That's why we have insurance, GoFundme, DC has the crime victims compensation fund, other resources to help with schooling and job resources. [/quote]

Oh, so “She should just go fund me a new car!”

You are such a cruel, cruel individual if you think that response answered anything. Insurance does not pay out the full value of the car, and her insurance costs will sky rocket. Again, just because buying a new car is like pocket change for you does not mean it’s as easy or reasonable to the vast majority of DC residents.

Also, why should we, as taxpayers, pay for a crime victim’s fund to pay for her car, when the answer is right in front of us: we need to prevent the car theft in the first place through instituting reasonable punishments against individuals committing such heinous crimes. It’s great we have these resources, and I fully support them, but we as citizens cannot afford to keep buying people car after car after care after their cars are stolen rather then actually putting in place common sense preventative measures to prevent the theft in the first case. It does not make economic sense.[/quote]

Kids with guns should be tried as adults. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics