Reply to Fairfax County Double Murder

Forum Index » Off-Topic

Reply to "Fairfax County Double Murder"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]For me, Juliana’s testimony was full of gaps and inconsistencies, unfortunately [/quote]

Much of it is corroborated by other evidence, such as the timing of the 911 calls, for instance. 
[/quote]

I think in her testimony she was trying hard to downplay her own role and behavior, but overall it’s basically what happened. Nothing else really makes sense, which is why we had hundreds of pages of discussion and speculation about this before she flipped. In particular, I think her lying in wait in the cul de sac (along with her full admission of what she was waiting for, and no other reasonable alibi) pretty much seals the deal on the catfish theory. No way she happens to be waiting for and coming back to the house upon the exact arrival of someone Christine was communicating with. I suppose Brendan could downplay his own involvement in the plot (despite conveniently lingering in the bathroom after going through the drive through), but it’s not super believable that either one of them catfished someone and then that person went so off script and stabbed Christine (conveniently) for them. What would be the purpose of the catfishing if not to stage a murder?

So when you consider that the jury is hearing all the facts for the first time, I think they won’t be able to see any other reasonable interpretation of these events. The idea that Christine was the person communicating with Joe is dead in the water if you look at the timeline surrounding Joe’s arrival to the home and the movements of Juliana and Brendan in coordination.

911 hang up call is also very significant in the timeline. Too much time elapses between the calls to reasonably believe their original claims.

I’m still hoping that tomorrow the prosecution has some forensic “clinchers” that can really seal the deal. At least one thing. But my guess is, all these facts are needed in context of each other and Juliana’s testimony was needed.

And circling back to the top of my post, I think Juliana was an active and willing participant in this and it’s upsetting she will basically get away with it. However, I’m not sure if she would have initiated this plot if not for Brendan. It also seems like the commonwealth felt they really needed this context for the case to seal the catfish theory and make the other facts fall into line. So if this is what was needed to put Brendan away and get that child to safety, I guess that is the priority.

[/quote]

DP here but adding on that Christine's phone was found downstairs, shut off and in a drawer.  She would not have done that if she were the one communicating with Joe IMO 1-  for safety reasons and 2- to make sure no one texting to say they were coming home early. Also, BB knew she wouldnt have been able to do find my iphone with it turned off if she somehow got out of the room. And there were telegram communications that morning before Joe arrived saying he was picking up a few more things. She did not communicate with him then go turn her phone off in a drawer on another floor.[/quote]

Really excellent points I hope the prosecution makes in closing.  As well as the point about the ridiculous coincidence that BB and JM were must minutes away and could come back when this started. [/quote]

i agree.

without judging anyone’s desires in the bedroom, 
i also think a previous poster was spot on with the comment that it’s unlikely that cb would go for this wild kinky rendezvous over a extra hour of sleep after a long shift on her feet as a nurse.

i’d prefer to have a summary witness tie up the forensics / evidence of scene manipulation over the obgyn.

jpm was a net positive for the cw. she’s just painfully dense. prepping her must have been tedious. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics