Reply to India one of the least racially tolerant countries?

Forum Index » Off-Topic

Reply to "India one of the least racially tolerant countries?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=CindyBindy][quote=Anonymous]

Not PP but Brazil and India are not even comparable.  The fact that person or others jokes about a type of hair is no more akin to racism than a red head joking about their hair color or a white person saying they are pale.  The fact of the matter is Brazilians are infinitely more accepting of phenotypic and cultural differences than most countries on the planet including the US.[/quote]

If a white person made a joke about nappy hair in America, do you think African Americans would just laugh it off? There has always been so much racial identity politics surrounding phenotypic differences that during the civil rights era, the Afro was an expression of celebrating pride in "nappy hair". I can guarantee you if someone who was not black made a joke about nappy hair in America today, the black community would blow up at him.

The point I was trying to make about the hair comment in Brazil - and I think I explained this above - was that in developing countries the sense of political correctness is different. Maybe people are misunderstanding that because I immediately talked about the Chinese cab driver next, and that was racism. In much of the developing world, people don't really have any sense of political correctness, or at least not the way Americans do. In India for example, you can't say the phrase "lower caste" or "untouchable" - the term is "scheduled caste" or "scheduled tribe". But I have also heard an Indian lady say to her tanned, sporty, outdoorsy child, "You look like a n*gro". Is she racist or just unaware that you can't say that? (and let's not discuss her color prejudice - that is different from racial prejudice) Well, I've seen how she treats Africans so I don't think she's racist, anymore than a white Brazilian who makes fun of "nappy hair". That was my point. Apologies if I didn't make this clear the first time.

[/quote]

PP you responded to...  It has no bearing whether AA's get sensitive when someone talks about their hair.  [b]It only proves that they are sensitive and insecure. [/b] The point when they are not sensitive and comments about differences are not a big deal will be a huge step forward in the US.  Brazil and several other countries are beyond that.  The US is not the standard here...   And this has little to do with developing vs developed country.  This has to do with in Brazil whites and blacks are more intertwined, have a shared culture and history.  In the US they are completely separate so they feel they need to walk on egg shells around eachother.[/quote]

[b]NP here and I am HIGHLY offended by your comment. How dare you insinuate that black people are sensitive and insecure about issues that stem from hundreds of years of oppression, racism and discrimination? Please get your head out of your ass[/b]. [/quote]

see, here's the problem. People can't discuss this stuff rationally - a post like this will always pop up and them people clam up and stop trying.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics