Reply to Lively/Baldoni Lawsuit Part 2

Forum Index » Entertainment and Pop Culture

Reply to "Lively/Baldoni Lawsuit Part 2"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]It is still all over the place and the accounts do not match. We have Blake’s deposition, but I’ve also read the make up artist’s account and it sounded nothing like Blake.

The makeup artist said Heath was knocking on the door and three women yelled “don’t come in! Don’t come in!” And he came in. That is not what Blake said in her deposition at all. [/quote]

Blake's deposition: "I don't know if it was unlocked at that point. He attempted to come in and we stopped him from coming in." And then, "He unexpectedly came to my trailer, knocked on the door, said, "We've got to talk." I said, "We can't talk right now. I'll be there in a few minutes. I'm getting done as fast as I can so we can have this meeting." He said, "Oh, no, we've got to talk now" --"

Vivian Baker deposition: "I -- I -- I think there was a knock. The -- what I remember most specifically is all three of us. So there must have been a knock, saying, "No, don't come in," and, "No, don't come in." It was quite loud. So that they wouldn't come in. It was myself, Anne, and all Blake saying it at the same time." And then, "After they opened the door, we all saw that it was Jamey. And there was a -- and Blake said -- I don't remember exactly what he said, but I remember her saying, "I'll talk to you about this later." Like, "Let me -- go ahead and move on. I'll get dressed. We'll talk about it later." And I think he said something to the tune of, "No, we'll do it now.""

Shelley Ann Carroll deposition:
Q You stated that you, Ms. Lively, and Ms. Baker verbally indicated something to the effect
of whoa, whoa whoa when Mr. Heath was opening the door; is that right?
A Yes.
Q And did you, Ms. Lively, Ms. Baker give a loud verbal indication that the trailer was occupied at that point in time?
A I believe we were speaking loudly.
...
Q And did Mr. Heath nevertheless open the door to the hair and makeup trailer?
A Yes.

Consistent.[/quote]

These are all different accounts. The makeup artist’s is the most jarring. Blake’s is actually a bit toned down.

I find it odd that Ryan Reynolds would berate Justin about going behind her back  asking her trainer her weight, but he doesn’t berate Heath for bursting in her room when she says don’t come in and refusing to leave when she’s undressed? And they’re walking around calling Justin a predator and he should be in jail but he’s not saying anything about this interaction with Heath?

Something is not adding up here. Ryan did not seem to have much distain for Heath in terms of singling him out. It was all directed toward Baldoni in terms of getting him removed from WME,etc.

I really wish I could read the original New York Times article but it’s now behind a pay wall and I’m not a subscriber.
[/quote]

All three women say the same thing. Good job trying to deflect from that. Your night school classes in misdirection are helping. Hang in there![/quote]

But all three women are not in fact saying the same thing. These are widely different accounts. Blake is not even remembering if the trailer was unlocked so she’s implying that someone could’ve let him in. I get it. It was a long time ago, but saying that these three women have the same accounts is just not accurate at all.

Was the trailer locked and someone opened it and told him to come back later? That is implied in one of these accounts. Or did he knock and someone told him from behind the door to come back later, but he refused. Or did he burst in like the makeup artist said and after they screamed, don’t come in don’t come in.

One is saying “there must’ve been a knock.” Which doesn’t sound like she is 100 percent certain there was a knock.

They’re all saying that Jamie Heath arrived at the makeup trailer that night. They’re all saying that there was a conversation that took place. No one is disputing that, but they have all reported widely different details and the details really matter here.

[/quote]

I think you are looking to be confused. They all said he knocked, and all three said "no, no, no" or "don't come in" or something to that effect. And then they all testify that he came in anyway, and that Lively asked to do the meeting when she was done, and he said that no, it had to happen now. The also all testified to hurriedly trying to finish their work and to being shaken and uncomfortable afterward, and that moving forward they would lock the makeup trailer door which was an unusual thing to do in that situation.

Blake was asked directly if the trailer door was locked. Since she wasn't near the door and didn't open it, she said "I don't know." Because she can't know if maybe Jamey had a key to the door and unlocked it from the outside to come in or something. She testified to him coming in after knocking, though.

The MUA who said "there must have been a knock" said that because she remembers all three of them telling whoever it was not to come in. She remembers that clearly. She may not remember the knock clearly, but she is thinking that they knew someone was outside and wanted in and that they objected, so there must have been a knock. Again, this is someone being honest about the limitations of their memory. Perhaps Jamey had called out "can I come in" and they all responded. She can't remember if someone knocked or they found out another way that they wanted in, but she remembers distinctly how the three women in the trailer responded.

If you've ever put together testimony from multiple people about the same sequence of events, you'd know this is remarkably consistent testimony. They do not contradict each other. Only Jamey's testimony (saying they said "come in") is inconsistent.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics