Reply to Trump Cancels Immigrant's Social Sec Numbers

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Trump Cancels Immigrant's Social Sec Numbers"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]On what grounds? [/quote]

The word “immigrant” as used by OP, is completely MEANINGLESS.

Did you mean “illegal immigrants” OP?  Maybe “aliens unlawfully present in the United States” perhaps?

If an alien is not here lawfully, why should they be receiving benefits, or expect to receive future benefits, reserved for U.S. citizens?

Aliens unlawfully in the USA are free to return to their home countries, where they can begin to pay into their own countries’ social security system.[/quote]

If you have an SSN, then you are either a citizen, or you are here lawfully and re authorized to work under a legal visa program (H1B, seasonal workers for tourism or agriculture, etc). Illegal immigrants to not get SSNs. They might get TINs if they work to report earnings. But that’s the IRS, not SSA. This punishes the legal immigrants who have followed all the laws and don’t work under the table, and have not committed any crimes.  And it keeps SSA from getting FICA taxes from immigrants who pay into the system, but often aren’t eligible for benefits to be paid out to them if they retire or disability. These workers are part of the reason the trust fund is still solvent.. And puts these workers in a position where they cannot rent a home, earn income except under the table, have a bank account— despite following the law.

I thought Rs wanted legal immigration?  Well, this punishes legal immigrants.

Why would you do this? Trump is finding that deporting millions of people is hard, so he is trying to force immigrants present and working legally to self deport. Because ot turns out not being able to get a W2 job, rent housing, get a car loan, have a bank account, etc, etc makes it almost impossible to live here

And knowingly marking people who aren’t dead as dead has a ripple effect that messes the whole SSA computer house of cards.  And it’s flat out illegal to lie when modifying government records (also, DOGe is blatantly ignoring an injunction that says they cannot access or modify SSA PII. Turns out the criminals rent the green card holders on H1Bs who are being marked dead. They are the DOGe Bros. I hope they all get shipped to El Salvador.

— SSA employee. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics