Reply to Fairfax schools to teach kids that you can change your sex not just gender

Forum Index » Metropolitan DC Local Politics

Reply to "Fairfax schools to teach kids that you can change your sex not just gender"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Good. Claiming to be a boy when you are a girl, or vice versa, does not make it so. [/quote]

Even that’s gender. They are now claiming that you can switch from male to female, not just man to woman . [/quote]

Though its called gender reassignment surgery, I think the way gender and sex are used these days, sex reassignment would be more accurate?  Since gender is used for social identity, but sex for physical reality. Surgery does change physical reality. [/quote]no surgery changes your chromosomes [/quote]

Except the gov’t doesn’t assign sex based on chromosomes. If they did, we’d have six or seven different sexes. Instead, the government accepts the word of a doctor who —for 99% of us— took a quick peek between our legs when we were 3 seconds out of the birth canal. Only a few newborns have testing to clarify gender and even then, there’s only legally an A or B option regardless of what their chromosomes show. I’m a cisgender female married to a cismale and mom to cisgender kids, but I took college human anatomy, genetics, and sociology so I know how arbitrary male and female designations can be on a purely chromosomal level.[/quote]
Intersex people are s tiny minority of people claiming to be trans [/quote]

which is not relevant to PP's point, which is that sex is not based on chromosomes, but on genitalia. Which, in fact, CAN be changed. And are also not the same as "gender".   [/quote]
An inverted penis isn’t a vagina[/quote]

Even with a sex change a man will never know what it means to have a period, birth a baby, nurse a baby, go through menopause or any other of the gazillion things thay make us women.

This whole movement is just a new twist on being anti woman and putting men before women.[/quote]

many genetic women never birth a baby.  many who do never nurse.   Many die before menopause.  A few never have a period.

By this movement do you mean A Gender dysphoria B The right of some to get surgery?  C. The terminology that calls those people women?   [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics