Reply to Do they have Halloween parties at Oakland Terrace ES?

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "Do they have Halloween parties at Oakland Terrace ES?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]People are obnoxious. It is not celebrated as a religious holiday at all. It is a cultural holiday. Will they try to ban thanksgiving celebrations next?

If they don't want their kid to do it they can send them to the alternate activities or pull them that afternoon. [/quote]

It is a holiday that violates many kids religions.

Every kid I have had whose family didn't believe in Halloween has been black.  That isn't true nationwide, but in this area it is mostly black families.  From my perspective, when schools are respectful of families who don't celebrate Christmas (which in this area is mostly white Jews), they need to be equally respectful of families who don't celebrate Halloween.  Saying it's "cultural" is beside the point.  Clothes are cultural, but excluding kids who wear hijab is still religious discrimination.  Food is cultural, but having a pig roast and not offering another option for Muslim and Jewish guests would still be religious discrimination.

I don't have a huge problem with a one day Halloween celebration, especially if there is a fun alternate option.  But in many classrooms Halloween becomes a month long celebration, with ghost stories and math worksheets where you count candy corn.  [/quote]

The only problem with that is most schools preach tolerance but then go against it.  My kid came home talking about God, easter, easter bunny, tooth fairy, all about Christmas, etc. and we don't celebrate any of those nor did.  She came home with coloring pages for easter and an easter basket.   So, do all or nothing.  If no Halloween, then no Christmas, no easter, etc.[/quote]

That is funny because my kids came home with worksheets about holidays that show religous symbols for all faiths but Christianity. The Christmas symbols were always secular examples while all the other examples for other religions were faith based.[/quote]

The irony for us is the school will not let the kids have a tiny cookie or anything sweet at lunch but give all kinds of cupcakes, popsicles and candy (including the easter basket).  They'd rather the kids have highly dyed cupcakes than a parent sending in one homemade cookie.    I don't see why we need any religion in school but obviously I am a minority in that.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics