Reply to Are string instruments better for the brain than wind?

Forum Index » General Parenting Discussion

Reply to "Are string instruments better for the brain than wind?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]Oh my.  I am a professional violinist, and a member of a family who has many professional musicians (one conductor, 3 pianists, 2 other strings players, and 1 oboe and trumpet).

I believe that most young kids really don't have the wind "strength" to start wind instruments at a very early age.  I think it is pure hogwash that it causes brain damage.  But I think there is a reason why most wind players don't start their studies until they're a bit older (age 10-12).

Yes, you can start your very young child more easily on a string instrument, or piano.  For strings, it is good to start early because a young child can more readily develop their ear.  Piano is difficult because of the finger dexterity required, and also the relatively more complex music -- but simple piano instruction can also begin early.

As to the poster who said energetic kids do better with wind instruments -- I'll say this.  Being a good wind (or brass) instrument player requires excellent lung capacity.  Some of that is genetic, and some of it is a matter of training.  It does not surprise me that kids who are athletic and have good lung capacity may have the genetic make up to be a good wind or brass player.  But -- and with due respect for my wind/brass relatives -- I also think that string instruments and piano are -- relatively speaking -- "harder" for young kids.  Unlike a clarinet that will produce the "right" note if you hit the right keys and blow, a string player must practice to be able to find that note on the violin or cello.  Kids who seem to excel at string instruments early in life may not be any more musically gifted or intelligent, but they have diligence.  Some kids just find it too darn hard and they quit (and maybe become great trumpet players later in life).

But, beyond my musings -- I would say don't worry about your friends.  Kids should choose the instrument that interests them the most.  As parents, be thrilled that they like their instrument and are playing music.  If you're choosing your child's instrument for any other reason (prestige, college admission, etc.) you're going about it all wrong.  :)
[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics