Reply to New rule this year??

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "New rule this year??"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Is there any mechanism for a parent to ask NCSL to look at whether the red card was appropriate?  [/quote]

It's entirely a judgment call, not application of the rules. It's the ref's judgment whether the offensive player had an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, and it's the ref's judgment whether the defender was attempting to play the ball.

If the ref had misapplied a rule -- say, awarding an indirect free kick for a handball -- you might have a case.

I think what you're really questioning is whether this rule is too harsh for U11. Well, it's the rule that everyone agreed to, it's not fair to the other team not to apply it. If your child wants to continue he needs to learn that under the rules of soccer, fouls in the penalty area are treated harshly, and fouling on a goal-scoring opportunity is treated harshly. The lesson is to play carefully in those situations.[/quote]

But it is a misapplied rule. Per Fifa rules, it's a caution not an expulsion. Expulsion is only warranted if the ref deemed the player wasn't going for the ball.

That said, I agree, NCSL isn't going to change anything. They may even add a suspension or 2 for complaining. [/quote]

You're not disagreeing with the application of the rule, you're disagreeing with the ref's interpretation of events. It's a judgment call by the ref whether the defender was attempting to play the ball.

"Kid on defense chases down another player on a breakaway and supposedly fouls him although from my view it seemed they were both going for the ball."[/quote]

So the attacking player was on a break away. The defender chased him down from behind and took the attacking player out. Yes card. The playing the ball really does not matter as much as you think it does. The discretion on card color is intent. The red card was most likely for a dangerous play. You can get all ball still get a card.

You have to work really hard to get a yellow at u11. A red card at u11 is even harder to get. You are not telling us the whole story. Refs remember dangerous players, refs talk to other refs. They will start to watch for your kid. Also other players remember these type of players and will go after them. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics