Reply to Trump demands that Israeli hostages released before 1/20 or he will destroy them

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Trump demands that Israeli hostages released before 1/20 or he will destroy them "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]In assuming that Israel already suspects that all the hostages are already dead and they have proceeded accordingly. [/quote]

No, Israel knows that not all the hostages are dead, it’s just that they don’t care.  Israeli military has long operated on the “Hannibal Directive” - that any IDF soldier under threat of being killed could be shot by other IDF.  This protocol was employed during Oct 7th when the order was given to use maximum force (i.e. lethal force) to prevent the return of vehicles to Gaza after the Oct 7 attack.  More here - https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/jul/07/israel-idf-hannibal-protocol-hamas-attack-haaretz

It is assumed that the Israeli military and political establishment has essentially applied the Hannibal principle to the hostages - whether alive or dead, the Israeli government will not negotiate for their return - the hostages are essentially dead to the Israeli government unless they have immediately actionable intelligence that they could use to conduct a recovery raid with minimal risk of casualties. (Fairly unlikely, but has happened once.)

It is thought that about half of the hostages (mix of military and civilian) are alive (50-60ish).[/quote]

[b]Where would they have been kept, underground for over a year? [/b]  Did Humas keep them all together,?  There is no way this many could still be alive and even if they be are Humas will return them DOA. I am looking forward to trump stopping all wars on Day 1!  What a joke.[/quote]

Yes, there are hundreds of miles of tunnels under Gaza, where the hostages are being kept. No, they are not all kept together. Some, early on were kept in homes above ground, but many were and are underground. [/quote]

Hamas is not hiding. They are killing Israeli soldiers which is why they dont want to do door to door combat to actually find the hostages. Israel can only do the only thing it knows to do which is carpet bomb because they cannot beat Hamas on the ground. After their latest military casualties when trying  to take over and defeat Hamas in North Gaza for the fourth time, Israel became so angry it decided to go nuclear literally. They've now resorted to using unheard of new weapons that vanish bodies completely within seconds. They are using small tactical nuclears in Gaza toward civilians and possibly their own citizens. This is Israel's war of annihilation but it doesnt seem to be annihilating Hamas only civilians. Their war is a failure just like all things from Netanyahu. Israel will likely be at civil war or do a military coup to get rid of Netanyahu within the next five years. Very sad state of affairs. I dont see any bright days ahead for Palestinians or Israelis.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics