Reply to Algebra 2 HN and Algebra 2 differences

Forum Index » Fairfax County Public Schools (FCPS)

Reply to "Algebra 2 HN and Algebra 2 differences"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

"Honors B vs non-honors A" is always a tough call. It partly depends on if the student is getting a comfortable B and just needs more time and practice for the advanced ideas to sink in, or if they are struggling and working really hard to get that B, and it's unsustainable. Also depends on whether Alg 1 was a struggle or an easy A, and if the student still remembers it well after a year of geometry.

Being bored in an easier class is a disservice. I know GPA is the false god we all lie prostrate to, but a more challenging class gives the *option* to grow and learn more, while the basic class holds you back unless you challenge yourself privately.[/quote]

This is exactly the dilemma we're facing.  My child had an easy A in Honors Algebra 1 (taught in 8th grade). Their initial plan was to take Honors Algebra 2 because they think their struggle is with Geometry specifically, not with the level of the class.  Has a solid B in Honors Geometry.  Doesn't seem to be working all that hard, but what they're making mistakes on ARE the application of the material.  But, I hear your point that not even being exposed to the application of the material is a big negative and probably a disservice.

The whole GPA situation is also tricky.  That Honors B is pulling my child's GPA down, while a regular A would give it a little boost.  I'm not sure what the colleges value more -- a lower GPA with harder classes taken, or just a higher GPA, when most classes are rigorous and just the math class isn't.  
[/quote]

If they are still keeping strong basics (they are mastering the straight forward portions of assessments) then I don't think being in honors is a disservice.  If they are struggling with the pace of honors to the point where even the basic things are falling apart, then move to regular algebra 2.

The majority of my gen ed algebra 2 sophomores still go on to take calculus AB senior year.  Some take precalculus and then realize they don't need calc for their intended college major and switch over to AP Stats or even regular stats.  Unless you are working towards an engineering degree at a top university, regular math is a fine path towards college acceptance.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics