Have you ended a relationship due to partner's weight?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I see a bunch of well-meaning but ignorant people responding here. While I agree that some people are simply slobs, there are others who for medical reasons have difficulty losing weight. For example, someone with hypothyroidism ( a fairly common disorder today due to stress and chemical pollutants) can have a very difficult time losing weight. In fact, many people with this condition GAIN weight and have incredibly slow metabolism. An endocrinologist once told me that I would need to eat 1/3 of a normal daily intake in order to lose weight and that is on top of exercising 6 days a week for 45 minutes per session.


I his is me plus I’m menopausal..... makes it 100x more difficult.



What is your average daily calorie intake for the past month?
$1000 says you don't accurately know.
Conclusion: you eat too much, THAT'S why you are overweight.



You are ignorant. I would have to eat 500 calories to lose weight and 1,200 to maintain the average weight. Both amounts are miniscule. I challenge you to tray eating that many calories on daily basis long term. Hypothyroidism is not a joke. And neither is hyperthyroidism (which often makes people lose weight and they are unable to gain it back). Both conditions are for life, even with treatment. Do not pass judgment if you are healthy, as fortunes in life can change overnight.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.

Anonymous
Chiming in to support the hypothyroid posters. I weighed 140 lbs, give or take 5 lbs, for my entire adult life. My pre-partum weight (1 pregnancy, 36) was 142 and my post-partum weight was 145.

I exercise DAILY, almost without fail. As in, approximately 355+ days per year. That exercise includes over 1000 miles of running, plus lifting and yoga and other cardio.

At 39.5, I gained 13 lbs in 4 months for no apparent reason, while working out daily and eating mindfully. 6 years later, those pounds are still there and no matter how good I am with the diet and exercise, they won't go away. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism a few years ago. So you can do everything right and still not be able to lose weight when your thyroid is screwed up. And if you're a person who started out not skinny and then doesn't exercise religiously, I can see it being a lot more than 13 lbs over the years.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Chiming in to support the hypothyroid posters. I weighed 140 lbs, give or take 5 lbs, for my entire adult life. My pre-partum weight (1 pregnancy, 36) was 142 and my post-partum weight was 145.

I exercise DAILY, almost without fail. As in, approximately 355+ days per year. That exercise includes over 1000 miles of running, plus lifting and yoga and other cardio.

At 39.5, I gained 13 lbs in 4 months for no apparent reason, while working out daily and eating mindfully. 6 years later, those pounds are still there and no matter how good I am with the diet and exercise, they won't go away. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism a few years ago. So you can do everything right and still not be able to lose weight when your thyroid is screwed up. And if you're a person who started out not skinny and then doesn't exercise religiously, I can see it being a lot more than 13 lbs over the years.


Your post doesn’t have much to do with the topic. 95 percent of obese folks don’t have what you have.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.



Are you the poster to whom I posed the questions above? If not, the questions still stand. She didn't find him "that heavy" to the point she turned down sex from the start, and she clearly says his personality was great. I am not asking others' experiences. I also think you didn't read her post. He WAS losing weight. And weight aside -- he was attractive to her as a person. I wonder if they'd waited to have sex, if it would have meant they could have communicated about it better and any weight issue might have mattered less because they'd have cared about each other more.
Anonymous
I didn't end it and I'm pretty I would make the decision to stay with DH if I had it to do over today. However, I do think I underestimated how much of an impact it would have on our life together. He has a bunch of comorbid health issues of which his excess weight is only one (and not even the most severe) and the reality is it's really, really tough. The whole "in sickness and health" thing can be brutal and I think people need to be more honest with themselves about how much they can take BEFORE they make a lifelong commitment to another person.
oldwisdom
Member Offline
Oh my 350lbs? Seriously? I don't want to judge but the point is it is not healthy anyway. You should try to convince her to go on a serious diet and workout.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:There was one season I called "Winter of the Fat Boys" because I kept meeting guys who outweighed me by a good 100 lbs. It's hard in the winter because everyone is so bundled up, you don't always realize how big they are until they get their clothes off. (I'm not a small person - 5'8" and 140 - but these guys weren't much taller than me, so that 100 lbs was a lot.)

I don't really mind a little beefiness, so I kind of rolled with it.

There was one guy I dated who was really nice but he was large and he was very sedentary. He belonged to a gym literally two blocks away - that actually had a skywalk he could use to walk there - and he never went because he was lazy. I am a daily exerciser and this drove me crazy. So I ended up dumping him. I had a hard time being attracted to a fat guy who did nothing to keep himself healthy.

A couple years later I ran into him and found out he had had a tumor in his abdomen the size of a basketball. Once it was removed, he had a lot more energy and he slimmed down quite a bit. I was really happy for him.


5'8 140 is a sz 6. You are a small person
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Chiming in to support the hypothyroid posters. I weighed 140 lbs, give or take 5 lbs, for my entire adult life. My pre-partum weight (1 pregnancy, 36) was 142 and my post-partum weight was 145.

I exercise DAILY, almost without fail. As in, approximately 355+ days per year. That exercise includes over 1000 miles of running, plus lifting and yoga and other cardio.

At 39.5, I gained 13 lbs in 4 months for no apparent reason, while working out daily and eating mindfully. 6 years later, those pounds are still there and no matter how good I am with the diet and exercise, they won't go away. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism a few years ago. So you can do everything right and still not be able to lose weight when your thyroid is screwed up. And if you're a person who started out not skinny and then doesn't exercise religiously, I can see it being a lot more than 13 lbs over the years.


Your post doesn’t have much to do with the topic. 95 percent of obese folks don’t have what you have.


Different poster her - actually, you would be surprised at the wide-spread occurrence of sub clinical (without apparent clinical manifestations) as well as undiagnosed hypothyroidism. It is due to chemical pollutants that we are surrounded with, anything from estrogen mimicking substances to toxins in water and pollution, but mainly toxic materials in our homes and offices.

People are on average much heavier today than in 1950s (an average woman in 1950s was 120lbs and today's average is 160lbs). What happened? We all know what happened (although mathematically this is the biggest increase in average ever since the dawn of the civilization) bu what underscores it all is an absolute, overwhelming, shocking amount of hormone disrupting chemical in food chain, water, and home.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.



Are you the poster to whom I posed the questions above? If not, the questions still stand. She didn't find him "that heavy" to the point she turned down sex from the start, and she clearly says his personality was great. I am not asking others' experiences. I also think you didn't read her post. He WAS losing weight. And weight aside -- he was attractive to her as a person. I wonder if they'd waited to have sex, if it would have meant they could have communicated about it better and any weight issue might have mattered less because they'd have cared about each other more.


You raise a valid point. I think some of it seems from my own weight issues. I definitely have a couple pounds to lose and I can’t imagine a guy I barely know bringing it up. I have been with a larger guy once - he was my first and this experience kind of was similar, only the actual sex was worst this time. The first guy had an issue with ending, this guy with keeping. Two, I think it puts a lot of pressure on someone - like hey, barely know you but you need to lose weight for us to have better sex. Finally, what if he does lose weight and we just don’t have that sexual chemistry? I am in my low 30’s and would like to have a family - it’s just hard to wait around and what he has to do isn’t overnight (and I can’t be certain that he would follow through or it would fix the issue).

One of my good friends recently divorced her husband because they were so mismatched sexually. It was super sad to watch. I have also stayed in a relationship with someone I deeply loved and it was never going to work out in the LR. I probably am cutting the cord early because breaking up when you care about someone just because you aren’t a good fit forever is THE WORST (I have been and would rather be cheated on).
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.



Are you the poster to whom I posed the questions above? If not, the questions still stand. She didn't find him "that heavy" to the point she turned down sex from the start, and she clearly says his personality was great. I am not asking others' experiences. I also think you didn't read her post. He WAS losing weight. And weight aside -- he was attractive to her as a person. I wonder if they'd waited to have sex, if it would have meant they could have communicated about it better and any weight issue might have mattered less because they'd have cared about each other more.


You raise a valid point. I think some of it seems from my own weight issues. I definitely have a couple pounds to lose and I can’t imagine a guy I barely know bringing it up. I have been with a larger guy once - he was my first and this experience kind of was similar, only the actual sex was worst this time. The first guy had an issue with ending, this guy with keeping. Two, I think it puts a lot of pressure on someone - like hey, barely know you but you need to lose weight for us to have better sex. Finally, what if he does lose weight and we just don’t have that sexual chemistry? I am in my low 30’s and would like to have a family - it’s just hard to wait around and what he has to do isn’t overnight (and I can’t be certain that he would follow through or it would fix the issue).

One of my good friends recently divorced her husband because they were so mismatched sexually. It was super sad to watch. I have also stayed in a relationship with someone I deeply loved and it was never going to work out in the LR. I probably am cutting the cord early because breaking up when you care about someone just because you aren’t a good fit forever is THE WORST (I have been and would rather be cheated on).

How does being fat make a guy bad in bed?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.



Are you the poster to whom I posed the questions above? If not, the questions still stand. She didn't find him "that heavy" to the point she turned down sex from the start, and she clearly says his personality was great. I am not asking others' experiences. I also think you didn't read her post. He WAS losing weight. And weight aside -- he was attractive to her as a person. I wonder if they'd waited to have sex, if it would have meant they could have communicated about it better and any weight issue might have mattered less because they'd have cared about each other more.


You raise a valid point. I think some of it seems from my own weight issues. I definitely have a couple pounds to lose and I can’t imagine a guy I barely know bringing it up. I have been with a larger guy once - he was my first and this experience kind of was similar, only the actual sex was worst this time. The first guy had an issue with ending, this guy with keeping. Two, I think it puts a lot of pressure on someone - like hey, barely know you but you need to lose weight for us to have better sex. Finally, what if he does lose weight and we just don’t have that sexual chemistry? I am in my low 30’s and would like to have a family - it’s just hard to wait around and what he has to do isn’t overnight (and I can’t be certain that he would follow through or it would fix the issue).

One of my good friends recently divorced her husband because they were so mismatched sexually. It was super sad to watch. I have also stayed in a relationship with someone I deeply loved and it was never going to work out in the LR. I probably am cutting the cord early because breaking up when you care about someone just because you aren’t a good fit forever is THE WORST (I have been and would rather be cheated on).

How does being fat make a guy bad in bed?


If he can’t keep it up, low desire, can’t get into certain positions, etc.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I maybe just indirectly did. We were dating a month or so. Honestly, loved his personality. He has over 100 lbs to lose and is working on doing so (and I definitely saw progress). However, the two times we had sex - it was not good. It was like he was going through the motions. Did not make me feel desired at all. Not sure if it has to do with his weight or if he is naturally a low drive guy, but if this is what sex is like now, it does not give me hope for the future.


If his personality was great, why didn't you feel that you and he could discuss and work on the sex?

Im not trying to be snarky, PP. I'm really asking. He was working on losing weight. There obviously were things about him that you found attractive and important enough to keep dating. But rather than say, hey, let's talk about what we both want in bed, let's talk about whether you're tired (losing weight can do that, short-term), etc., you dropped him because the sex wasn't good enough for you. So you'd drop a guy whose personality you loved because of so-so sex the first two times, only a month into dating, without any communication with him about sex? Asking seriously--if you had waited longer to have sex and had known him better as a person, do you think you would have tried instead to work on sex as a couple?

Have you been with a man that heavy? Lots of physical problems once you get to that weight that really aren’t solvable without weight loss. Some of it chemical, some of it just physics. And the main player is very small.



Are you the poster to whom I posed the questions above? If not, the questions still stand. She didn't find him "that heavy" to the point she turned down sex from the start, and she clearly says his personality was great. I am not asking others' experiences. I also think you didn't read her post. He WAS losing weight. And weight aside -- he was attractive to her as a person. I wonder if they'd waited to have sex, if it would have meant they could have communicated about it better and any weight issue might have mattered less because they'd have cared about each other more.


You raise a valid point. I think some of it seems from my own weight issues. I definitely have a couple pounds to lose and I can’t imagine a guy I barely know bringing it up. I have been with a larger guy once - he was my first and this experience kind of was similar, only the actual sex was worst this time. The first guy had an issue with ending, this guy with keeping. Two, I think it puts a lot of pressure on someone - like hey, barely know you but you need to lose weight for us to have better sex. Finally, what if he does lose weight and we just don’t have that sexual chemistry? I am in my low 30’s and would like to have a family - it’s just hard to wait around and what he has to do isn’t overnight (and I can’t be certain that he would follow through or it would fix the issue).

One of my good friends recently divorced her husband because they were so mismatched sexually. It was super sad to watch. I have also stayed in a relationship with someone I deeply loved and it was never going to work out in the LR. I probably am cutting the cord early because breaking up when you care about someone just because you aren’t a good fit forever is THE WORST (I have been and would rather be cheated on).

How does being fat make a guy bad in bed?


If he can’t keep it up, low desire, can’t get into certain positions, etc.


This, but more importantly for every thirty pounds you lose an inch of length. It adds up.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Chiming in to support the hypothyroid posters. I weighed 140 lbs, give or take 5 lbs, for my entire adult life. My pre-partum weight (1 pregnancy, 36) was 142 and my post-partum weight was 145.

I exercise DAILY, almost without fail. As in, approximately 355+ days per year. That exercise includes over 1000 miles of running, plus lifting and yoga and other cardio.

At 39.5, I gained 13 lbs in 4 months for no apparent reason, while working out daily and eating mindfully. 6 years later, those pounds are still there and no matter how good I am with the diet and exercise, they won't go away. I was diagnosed with hypothyroidism a few years ago. So you can do everything right and still not be able to lose weight when your thyroid is screwed up. And if you're a person who started out not skinny and then doesn't exercise religiously, I can see it being a lot more than 13 lbs over the years.


Your post doesn’t have much to do with the topic. 95 percent of obese folks don’t have what you have.


Different poster her - actually, you would be surprised at the wide-spread occurrence of sub clinical (without apparent clinical manifestations) as well as undiagnosed hypothyroidism. It is due to chemical pollutants that we are surrounded with, anything from estrogen mimicking substances to toxins in water and pollution, but mainly toxic materials in our homes and offices.

People are on average much heavier today than in 1950s (an average woman in 1950s was 120lbs and today's average is 160lbs). What happened? We all know what happened (although mathematically this is the biggest increase in average ever since the dawn of the civilization) bu what underscores it all is an absolute, overwhelming, shocking amount of hormone disrupting chemical in food chain, water, and home.


I’m not sure what your point is.

This may be true but my office is filled with fairly thin people, and I’m sure we drink the same water and shop at the same grocery stores as you do.

Are you saying that it’s not Americans’ fault that they are fat?
post reply Forum Index » Relationship Discussion (non-explicit)
Message Quick Reply
Go to: