The terrorists aren't real Muslims...

Anonymous
Riots and looting are a great American pastime of the poor and disenfranchised...just like burning couches in the street after a big college sports win is an American thing.

Jihad isn't American. It just isn't.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Riots and looting are a great American pastime of the poor and disenfranchised...just like burning couches in the street after a big college sports win is an American thing.

Jihad isn't American. It just isn't.


+1 Culture is everything. Religion is but one aspect of culture as are customs and traditions and language and arts and literature and politics and economies and social hierarchies. All of that crap adds up to whether the poor and disenfranchised in one country riot and loot whereas the poor and disenfranchised in another country maim and kill. It's cultural.
Muslima
Member

Offline
Anonymous wrote:
Muslima wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Muslima wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Muslima wrote:Racism, Religious Bigotry and Discrimination does not promote a more "civil" society. "Where justice is denied, where poverty is enforced, where ignorance prevails, and where any one class is made to feel that society is an organized conspiracy to oppress, rob and degrade them, neither persons nor property will be safe." - Frederick Douglass

Except the ranks of ISIS are apparently full of young Muslims from the Western countries where you cannot possibly say they lacked opportunity for advancement.


Read about ISIS history, how it started and what they are fighting for. They are able radicalize young western people, some of whom have identity crisis, just like young Americans join gangs, do drugs, get drugs, you will find some young Muslims joining these groups because they give them a sense of identity and belonging. Radicalization is an individualized process so I can't paint them all with the same brush, but most of them are young men and women looking to belong to a group/movement that gives them a purpose. There are many underlying reasons, and this is just one of them .


Then there is no reason to say that terrorist groups attract only the poor, the dispossessed and the uneducated.


I did not say that

then what exactly did you mean with your douglass quote?


Re-read the Quote, that is not what it says
Muslima
Member

Offline
Anonymous wrote:Riots and looting are a great American pastime of the poor and disenfranchised...just like burning couches in the street after a big college sports win is an American thing.

Jihad isn't American. It just isn't.


Yeh? That's why there is an American who just got arrested for plotting an attack on the U.S Capitol.....
Anonymous
Was he plotting the attack on the Capitol in the name of Islam? That's jihad, Sweetie.

Or was he just a crazy ass mentally ill good old white boy? Because when mentally ill white boys shoot up schools, theaters or government buildings, they aren't doing it in the name of "religion." They're just doing it because they are mentally ill (like the crazy white bartender who wanted to spike Boehner's drink and kill him...crazy ass white boy, but not an evil jihadist).

Feel me, Sista?

Anonymous
And just to clarify, Sista:

When Americans are brainwashed by Islamic nut jobs and inspired to commit acts of terrorism domestically and abroad, that's the epitome of being Unamerican...and kudos to the extremists for using religion to recruit dimwitts and equip them to commit evil acts of violence against innocent people...in the present day world that's a uniquely Muslim thing (not an American thing) thanks to Al Queda, ISIS, et al.

Sure we have some bizarre religious crazies in the US...but they are teeny tiny groups, not well organized militant armies that number in the tens of thousands and are heavily armed. Why??? Because our government wouldn't tolerate that. And perhaps more importantly, because Homey don't play that.

And at the risk of opening up the floodgates for flamers, have you noticed that many of our so called "homegrown terrorists" who operate as lone wolves or jet off to Arab nations to train have genetic connections to Arab countries? I mean, Jake Smith isn't the typical "American" flying to the Middle East to join the terrorists...
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
jsteele wrote:Piers Morgan is an idiot. I would like to think that, regardless of all our other differences, we could al agree on that. Morgan has no right to tell someone what their religion is or is not. Individuals get to identify their own religions. The vast majority of people who consider themselves Muslims don't practice or believe in the horrific practices of IS. Many members of that vast majority have already made statement disassociating Islam as they practice it from IS's version.

However, there is a critical problem of defining whether IS are "real Muslims". The roots of the Islam practiced by IS and by al-Qaidia are the same roots of the official Islam of Saudi Arabia. Were Saudi Arabia take steps to delegitimize IS, it would undermine its own religious authenticity. The US is apparently in no position to rock the boat with the Saudis. Ironically, Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood could have been a useful opponent to IS and al-Qaida. But, due to the US-supported coup in Egypt, those guys are all dead, arrested, or in hiding.


Don't forget that the Saudis are one of the biggest violators of human rights and one of the biggest facilitators of human rights atrocities.

This. Time to distance ourselves from the Saudis, until they stop their abuse of the innocents.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:There are dozens of examples now circulating of major Muslim organizations and leaders condemning and denouncing the Charlie Hebdo attackers, to include CAIR, the Council on American-Islamic Relations, Arab League, Ahmadiyya Muslim Community USA, Muslim Council of Britain, French Muslim Council (CFCM), Union of Islamic Organizations of France (UOIF), Dalil Boubakeur, imam at the mosque of Paris, Hassen Chalghoumi, imam of the Drancy mosque in Paris’s Seine-Saint-Denis suburb, The Islamic Cooperation Organization (ICO), The National Council of Canadian Muslims (NCCM), Canadian Council of Imams, Ahmadiyya Muslim Community of Canada, Muslim Canadian Congress, Al-Azhar, Saudi Arabian Government, Qatar Foreign Ministry, United Arab Emirates Foreign Ministry, Malaysia's Prime Minister, Morocco's King Mohammed, Indonesia's Foreign Ministry, Egypt Foreign Ministry, Turkey Foreign Ministry, Lebanon Foreign Ministry, Iran Foreign Ministry, even Hezbollah and Hamas have denounced the Paris attackers. Yet what we continue to hear from FOX News and idiots like Piers Morgan are "why aren't any Muslims stepping up to denouce this?"


Denouncing something and taking action are unfortunately not going hand in hand.... That applies to all the entities that are capable of taking actions, but not doing so.... Or not doing what they could do. (Referring to several foreign ministries listed and heads of state)
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous



Anonymous wrote:
Mormons are not Christian.

They believe Jesus was the son of God and in his resurrection. Why are the not Christian?

Mainstream religions think if them as a cult. The religion is not very old and was an American religion. So many Mormons left a mainstream religion to join the Mormon church, add in the isolation (both self and from outside) of the early Mormon society, the strong personality and strange leadership in the early days and people think cult. Also Mormons are a growing, actively recruiting religion. This threaten many mainstream religions which are not growing. Remember the religion is so young that we have contemporary third party accounts of the history of the church preserved. So one can read the accounts in the Book of Mormon and read contemporary sources(news paper, court records etc) in English that give a different perspective on the same account. Think of having court records, newspaper articles, county, state, and federal records in English of the Jesus and how Christianity would look like. Read "Under the Banner of Heaven".


What difference does it make how old a religion is?

It's all the same. In 1000 years, people may be worshiping rocks.
Anonymous
Muslima wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Riots and looting are a great American pastime of the poor and disenfranchised...just like burning couches in the street after a big college sports win is an American thing.

Jihad isn't American. It just isn't.


Yeh? That's why there is an American who just got arrested for plotting an attack on the U.S Capitol.....


So this American was fighting against the oppressor (aka - our government) to fight an injustice?

And that constitute jihad?

I thought jihad was ethical.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I'm not a big can of Piers, but I think he and Rushdie have a good point that the violence won't end unless/until the Muslim world puts an end to it. Christians and Jews (and atheists and wiccans) can't fix the problem. Your point about Saudi Arabia is a prime example of what needs to be done: Muslim and Arab nations stepping up to fix the problem in their own countries...at least as a starting point.

And I'm sorry the terrorists and extremists don't seem to understand that the rest of the world really isn't interested in what they do in their own countries. In fact, we seem to have a high tolerance for human rights violations (heck, we even tolerate mass kidnapping, rape and slaughtering...sometimes even genicude)...as long as they keep it in their own countries. But when they prompt terrorists to attack abroad, they are actively provoking a response. If they really wanted to enforce laws more appropriate for the Middle Ages, no one would care...unless/until it affected the rest of the world.



I agree that Muslims need to bring reform from within. No outside agency can do that. Today I watched a video of an innocent woman stoned and trampled to death by an angry mob, for allegedly burning the Koran. This was in Afghanistan I am still horrified. Can't unsee that.
All I could think was "No religion or book has more vAlue than a human life! If someone from my faith would do that in the name of religion, I would not associate with that religion.
Muslims have to take a stance and speak up and do what is right. Self organize and speak up against injustice. This, Before the worlds hatred takes a toll on Islam. Religion is a man made construct not an identity.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I agree with Jeff. We don't decide other people's religions. This is just like those who say Mormons aren't Christian. In reality Mormons say they are Christian therefore they are Christian. Or the way Orthodox Jews refer to themselves as religious, basically implying that Reform, Conservative Jews are not doing it right.


I say I'm the Queen of England, therefore I'm the Queen of England. I like how this works.
jsteele
Site Admin Offline
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I agree with Jeff. We don't decide other people's religions. This is just like those who say Mormons aren't Christian. In reality Mormons say they are Christian therefore they are Christian. Or the way Orthodox Jews refer to themselves as religious, basically implying that Reform, Conservative Jews are not doing it right.


I say I'm the Queen of England, therefore I'm the Queen of England. I like how this works.


Seriously? Do you really believe that is a good analogy? There are laws that identify who is Queen of England. Individuals don't simply choose that position. In most cases, and certainly not in Islam, there is no similar system in place for identifying an individual's religion. You aren't exactly issued a membership card.
post reply Forum Index » Political Discussion
Message Quick Reply
Go to: