I’ll admit that this isn’t a fully thought-out idea, but I didn’t want to take the other threads in yet another direction. Feel free to poke all kinds of holes in this one. I just needed the distraction going into this weekend.
What if … … CHRVA books a facility like The St. James for Indigenous Peoples Day and Election Day weekends for tryouts. However, this event wouldn’t replace the current tryout "schedule." It’s just more of a consolidated opportunity for prospective players to check out as many clubs as possible. My initial thinking is that schools are already closed three or four days over those weekends, so this event shouldn't conflict with most school-related activities. The facility is configured for a large volleyball tournament (The St. James has 9 courts in the Court House, and can possibly have another 20 or so in the Field House). Two or three courts will be used for warm-ups and free play, which would be monitored by club coaches. More on that below. Only hold tryouts for one or two age groups per day. Something like: Indigenous Peoples Day (IPD) Saturday: 14s IPD Sunday: 12s & 13s IPD Monday: 10s & 11s Election Day (ED) Friday: 18s ED Saturday: 17s ED Sunday 16s ED Monday 15s Clubs pay the average one-day local CHRVA tournament fee (~maybe $300, I’m guessing). Participating clubs will get one court to conduct their own dedicated tryout all day, which would also be outfitted with appropriate video recording … just like most tournaments. Clubs would also volunteer one or two coaches to monitor an hour on the warm-up/free-play courts. Coaches can encourage players to go check out their dedicated court based on what they see in free-play. To encourage participation by the clubs, make this event a requirement for entering a team into Bid Regionals. In other words, for the "16s day" (ED Sunday, from above), any club that participates will be one step closer to qualifying its 16s team(s) for Bid Regionals. Clubs can also have a table on the main/upper level to promote their offerings, fees, practice and tournament schedules, and accept tryout forms. CHRVA can also accept memberships at a table as well. NOTE: Parents won’t be allowed on the bottom floor where the courts are, but can view everything from the main level or the stands in the Field House. Athletes will pay an average tryout fee, say in the $50 to $100 range. With that fee, they get all-day access to the facility and can try out for any club that’s present. At check-in, they’ll get a bib number with a QR code, have their photo taken with the bib (I recall this is something that The St. James already does with its own VB tryouts, so the capability is already there), and have their measurements taken (height, standing reach, block jump, approach jump, etc.). As the athletes move around the facility that day, they can scan their own QR code at a court, which would later provide their check-in information to the club. At the end of the day, the clubs will get all the necessary attendee data for the players that visited their court. Assuming the clubs get the data they need as well as video footage from their court in a reasonable amount of time, offers can go out two days after the event (but not before!) So, if the 16s day is a Sunday, participating clubs can start making offers to athletes after 12 noon on the following Tuesday. All offers would be valid for three days. Offers would only go to athletes who “checked in” at a club’s court, so someone from the club should have seen the athlete that day at their court. After three days, clubs can reach out to any attending athlete to fill remaining roster slots. Again, I’m just letting this fantasy play out in my head. I’m sure there are logistical and other challenges that would need to be addressed. I know that every area club wouldn't be able to participate on the same day. Parking? Have high school booster organizations arrange a fundraiser to busses from schools to the facility or parents arrange carpools. Food? Have some food trucks line the main outdoor entrance. And so on. A site like The St. James already has a ton of amenities (medical staff for injuries, as an example), so some needs are already addressed. Anyway, I hope I’ve provided a momentary distraction for what could be a long weekend. : ) November 4th update I'm not going to bump this thread with a new response, but I've read the responses posted through Nov. 2nd. As I believe I said in the original post, this wasn't a fully-formed thought and I didn't intend to pitch this as a complete replacement for the current tryout "system." I was just wondering if a consolidated event would allow more potential players to get in front of more clubs without zipping all over the DMV on a single weekend. Just trying to think a little differently than what we've currently got but with a little more detail to help visualize the possibilities. No, this solution wouldn't be for every player or club in every situation. ![]() . |
League sports have been running centralized tryouts forever. club teams don't cooperate enough to get something like this done. |
Not all schools are closed for election weekend. This isn’t a thing because some of the major public schools are closed. No, you can’t change an entire process with this idea. |
And adding to my post above, my kids happen to be in a district that’s off but I’m never off. I don’t want to take off a day to take them to tryouts. Those are regular work days for a lot of people. |
Let’s run the wild scenario this is the set up. Much of the traditional tryout is watching the girls play together and see how they vibe. If the 16s, for example, split among their choosing of club courts, how do you ensure fairness in determining workability with teammates. If you show up at Club A with weaker players, you may hurt your chances while the stronger plays we all happened to start on Club B And Cs court. Seems like that could effect tryouts. |
I had a similar thought. For more competitive teams especially, tryouts often involve a lot of gameplay like scenarios and they will have a few prospective players mixed in with the returners they expect back to get a sense of chemistry and compatibility. Perhaps clubs could opt in to something like this if they believed it would result in them being able to see more potential players in single day, but I think there would be a lot of resistance. Another issue is that CHRVA covers a pretty broad geographic area and includes Delaware and the northeastern part of WV. Forcing players to drive 2-3 hours to tryouts when they can really only play for the clubs that are logistically practical for them does not seem very efficient. |
I don't think it would work for several reasons. St James doesn't have enough parking for the number of players that would show up. While St. James may be convenient for VA clubs, it will be quite inconvenient for MD clubs. You could set up something in several areas, but what are you going to do with the players who want to try for teams located in both VA and in DC? How about the players who want to try for teams located in both MD and in DC? |
What are you going to do about the players who don't want their club to know where else they try out? |
There has got to be a better way than the current system. |
It doesn’t fix the problem that if a kid gets sick on a single weekend they are basically screwed for the year. That seems not ideal. |
What does fix that problem is going to clinics that are your DD’s top few clubs. A few years ago, my DD got an offer from a club even though she had to miss their tryout due to a HS playoff match. They had watched her play at their clinics and knew they wanted her. As long as the offer is made after the start of the open tryout period and you’ve paid for a tryout, it’s within the rules. |
For those living in Chantilly and beyond, a centralized place like the St. James is inconvenient at best.
And private and parochial schools don't have Election Day off nor do I so how would I get my kid out there? St. James is an expensive venue. Players woukd need to pay more than your estimated "$100 fee to offset the cost that coaches woukd need to rent out/close off the St. James for tryouts. |