I'm planning a 9 day solo trip this fall and torn between Portugal (Lisbon/Porto) and Spain (Barcelona/Madrid/Seville). I enjoy cities and plan to take trains as opposed to renting a car, but I haven't been to either country. Which would you choose? |
Cheaper to fly into Portugal and head South. From there, take the train to Seville. Spend a few days in Portugal and a few in Spain. TAP Air Portugal is pretty affordable and you get free stopovers in either Lisbon or Porto if you decide to fly to Spain rather than take the train. |
I mean, neither sounds like a great place for a solo trip to me. I would just do Barcelona and then the south of France, personally. |
Oh wow, this is a great tip, thank you! |
Train from where? There's no trains from Portugal to Seville. |
Yeah-- do not do this. It is a gigantic pain to go from Portugal to Spain, there are no easy direct public transit options except flying. easy enough to travel lisbon-porto though, If you like easy train travel. Barcelona Madrid Seville is super duper easy, 2.5 hours between each city with lots of trains all day. |
Lisbon to Porto is also an easy train ride. |
I leave for Lisbon in a few days. We are flying into Lisbon and doing an overnight in a flat in Sintra so we can beat crowds the next morning to see Pena Palace and Quinta de Regaleira. The day before we are exploring Lisbon and doing a day trip to Tomar. Obidos or Cascais is a maybe for the day after Sintra depending on how we feel. You can fly Ryan Air and get flights to Seville and anywhere else pretty cheap. |
I would do San Sebastian and then train to Barcelona |
I would choose Spain over Portugal. This one is a no brainer. |
Have done both and disagree. Each has their oen charms. |
I visited both places, but if I must pick one, Portugal is my preference over Spain. Why? It's safer in relation to Spain as seen here: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-peaceful-countries; when it comes to costs like accommodation, eating and moving around, Portugal tends to be slightly cheaper than Spain does. Also, the country of Portugal is smaller compared with how big Spain is. If you can spend 9 days, that's perfect for Portugal. A normal plan should take at least seven days, so you have enough time to really experience the local ways of life and traditions. You can also spend around five or six days in Portugal if you plan to visit mainly the big cities and then use the extra days for traveling in Spain. If your trip is 12 or more days, I would recommend choosing Spain. Finally, I cannot speak Spanish or Portuguese. According to the EF English Proficiency Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EF_English_Proficiency_Index Portugal ranks eighth worldwide in English skills, whereas Spain is positioned at thirty-fifth.
I traveled around Lisbon by myself, which wasn't too hard because you can get to many places on foot. However, when I went to Porto, I decided it was best to use a guide from the area https://gowithguide.com/portugal/porto/guides |
I agree with much of what you say. But as someone who lives in the United States and is comfortable here, safety in Spain and Portugal really isn't a concern. Both look safer than the US, according to the map. And like I said, I feel safe here. |
Portugal. Much smaller, less expensive and easier to get around. The train from Lisbon to Porto only takes three hours. Porto is a great city with a lot of energy given the largest university is there. |
Fly to Lisbon. Get over your jet-lag in an easy city to get around by foot, by metro and by Taxi. If you want to see more of Portugal - easy train up to Porto and I believe there is a train from Lisbon to the Algarve - in Southern Portugal if you want to see the beaches. However once you are there - it's not as easy to get around.
If you want to do both Portugal and Spain. You could fly between Lisbon and Madrid - see both main cities. For me personally, I have visited both countries and enjoyed Portugal more. For me, I loved the food, Lisbon and it felt safe and the pace of life matched my own. Depending on when you are going and if you decide to go to Spain - a few years ago we planned to take the train from Madrid to Seville - but made the mistake of planning to book the train upon arrival - unfortunately no spaces on the trains and we had to be in Seville for a specific event - we ended up renting a car and it was a wonderful and easy drive so I wouldn't discount that as a means of transportation. It allowed us to get places off the beaten track. |