I would also recommend Anne at Tranquil Space in Dupont Circle. She is nurturing in her practice.

I'm due in January with my first child and have mixed feeling about RH&J. My first appt with an OB was with McKanders who didn't seem at all interested in my pregnancy but rather asked me where I shopped for my clothes because she really liked my shirt. What? Not a good start. I really disliked her and am shocked that they brought her on as a new Dr. since I haven't read one nice thing about her on this thread.
I've met with Hill and Sartawi and they both were fine. That said, I would like to aim for a natural birth. I have asked the OBs that I have met with if they object and they all seem fine with it but I have this sense that as I get closer to my due date, they are going to change their tune.
Has anyone had a natural birth with this practice? We are planning on using a doula as well.