What would be great would be student shuttle hubs at various points in the city. For example, an elementary hub that picks up at designated times at Tenleytown and/or a few other stops that are central to where the biggest proportion of the commuting populations are coming from, then follows a set route to each of the designated elementary schools on that route. Repeat for middle school and high school (particularly for MacArthur). Then neighborhood parents can coordinate carpools to various hubs and feel comfortable putting younger kids on the bus. Even better if drop off points are outside of Ward 3, then school commuters don't have to go far out of their own neighborhoods at all. Like the Deal buses, but designated ONLY for students and drop off at the MacArthur schools as well as J-R schools.
The Ward 3 NIMBY is missing the mark not because it's inherently wrong to dislike the reliance on cars for school drop off and pickup that DC has created, but because PP doesn't realize that all of us who do that commute HAVE considered transit and would love a viable transit option. But DC just doesn't care (probably because the volume of cross town school commute traffic is actually very low) and is actually proposing to cut existing service. |
From what neighborhood to where? |
From the black neighborhood to the white one. For the kids who matter. |
Gains made due to PK3 & 4 are in illusion. Studies have shown head start kids (on average) are behind again by 3rd grade. Many who aren't behind in 3rd grade are behind by high school. Nothing the schools do can make up for an unstable homelife. |
Shepherd park to ward 3 elementary school. I didn’t organize it, but it was a normal thing someone on the school listserve had handled (and then passed off) for years. |
Falling behind again in 3rd grade is not ideal, but it's 1000x better than being continually behind in k-2nd. Being on track through 2nd grade means that the Headstart kids are actually learning to read, which is foundational to the ability to catch up later. Of course pk3&4 cannot fully erase the deficits caused by unstable homes from pk3-12th grade, but it's still well worth the effort and pays serious dividends. |
At the end of the day, kids who come from families that don’t care about parenting, education, holding down a job, who scream profanities at their kids in public, smoke weed I front of kids etc…are not going to succeed. Stop blaming the schools. DC just keeps passing kids each who can’t read or write or do basic math and then everyone blames the teachers cause the kids are a mess by middle school |
Individual teachers and individual principals, might not be able to. But a school district or a country can. Those kids need longer school days and longer school years, as much time as possible in a positive, safe, nurturing environment with ample free nutritious actual food. These kids need to be supported by adults who care about their jobs, care about not screaming profanities at children, who don't smoke weed, who recognize they as adults cannot spend any time on social media while in the school building. These kids need out-of-school programs staffed with young adults with the same values as the school staff described above. This can be achieved with investments, especially if those investments aren't stolen or squandered by corruption. |
You forgot to add if they don’t have their schools shut down for more than an entire year. |
This is all great if the kids come to school. Attendance for many kids who have turbulent home lives is awful. All these programs sounds great but if a kid misses 40% of the school year or is two hours tardy every day, this won’t help. And who is going to staff these longer school days and school years? |
Or you could go to your neighborhood school? |
DC forced you to enter the school lottery? |
No |
+1. Nobody is complaining here except the Ward 3 NIMBY. |
DC would be ecstatic if kids only missed 40% of the school year |