What high schools track other than math? |
I mean, I'm sure that person is just making internal justifications since her kid didn't get in. Very common. |
| I know a kid who goes there (not my kid). The impression this kid relays -- without ever really saying as much -- is that it's a fairly competitive and cliquish place, where it's hard to get by without a good friend group. |
Or maybe like me, that poster seems the weak academic offerings, lack of ECs and sports, combined with the low standards from dcps and went elsewhere? Sorry even the lowest rated suburban high school has better academics than Walls. |
Reality is Walls is just a mediocre school. It’s nothing special. The good schools in the burbs and the magnets are so, so much better. Most people know that what Walls has going for it is that there is a decent cohort of academically minded kids and less behavioral issues. That’s basically it. Course offerings limited and doesn’t do compare to burbs, many teachers just clocking it in, principal is not good, facilities is poor, limited EC and sports. This is supposed to be DC’s magnet school and it could potentially be so much better. Now OSSE is trying to destroy the one thing that is good about it is the top academic performance of the kids and student body. |
These things are trade-offs for being a much smaller school than the suburban high schools or JR. Some kids and parents value the experience of being in a 600-student school vs a 2500-student school. I think some teachers are "just clocking it in" but most are good. Can't disagree with you on the other points. |
Is this informed by having or having had a kid at Walls? Or general pontification? Most teachers are engaged and happy to teach the cohort. Scaffolding like Writing center or SAT prep if you need it. College outcomes are good for a chunk of the group but may be masked by ability-to-afford for some of the cohort. Good group of kids who have fun together from what I have seen. A ridiculous part of a kid’s life outcomes are explained by maternal education levels, so we’re all playing at the margins with this my suburban or independent school can beat up your Walls crap. |
What?? What are you talking about with ability to afford when it comes to college outcomes? Walls has the lowest at risk in this city after Basis. It’s like 7%. JR, Banneker, DCI all have significantly higher at risk, 2 times almost and higher so Walls absolutely should have better college outcomes than these 3 schools, much better. |
Compared to *private* school students, Walls kids are more likely to have limits on their ability to pay. |
Walls (and BASIS) are full of many truly middle class families (we are one and we know our kids friends, etc) who may be less inclined to pay $90k per year. That's what the PP is talking about. |
No one is making that comparison. But it is a fair comparison to the schools above. |
I’m so angry that the crown jewel of dcps is so mediocre. I wish there was more for my kids. |
The comparison is made by school admissions officers. Geography ia one of the ways they slice and dice. |
I was responding to a poster's bafflement at the following statement: College outcomes are good for a chunk of the group but may be masked by ability-to-afford for some of the cohort." |
Sorry, just getting back to this, re: the bolded part of my post—No, This was the email they sent to families not teachers. Our personal email was always correct and DCPS successfully sent us other emails just not this one. Basically, we just had the extreme bad luck to submit our application on Jan 29 at 8 pm. DCPS sent the [Action requested by Feb 9] email to applicants a few hours earlier and it never went it out again. Kicking myself because I had actualy submitted our application a few days before that but then unsubmitted it to wait for a more up-to-date 8th grade report card (which I don’t know why they request since they don’t even look at) to upload. If I’d left it alone I would have gotten the information about Feb 9! Essentially, it was about when you submitted. Which is crazy since application submission date should have no bearing on anything. Whether you submit Dec 15 or Feb 2 all applicants should have be given the same information about any deadlines. And again, DCPS (up to the Chancellor office) knows this and has admitted to it privately. I suspect they just didn’t want to deal with the fall out of admitting it publicly. And I don’t know if they told the Selective HS’s either. I suspect not since SWW still seems to think we were being sent reminders. MSDC also has no system to recognize or catch a bounce back email, so they just kept sending “reminder” emails to the same incomplete email address 🙁. They don’t cc families. Obviously i messed up with the email and not checking soon enough, and that will haunt me for a long time. But if DCPS had just sent the email about Feb 9 one more time, on Feb 3 when ALL the applications were in, I think my daughter would be in different situation right now and I’d be in a better state of mind. Also, FWIW, I have a kid at Walls and I certainly agree it’s not perfect. But it’s good and would have been good for her and was where she wanted to go. |