Going deeper into the math itself (like AoPS) or doing more cross-curricular applications involving technology and statistics/regressions? |
Thank you for this. I just asked DC's teacher for a book and she responded in minutes saying one was ready for pickup. |
Deeper. multiple times I would suggest one of my kids try it and they would state that the book’s examples and problems were way too easy compared to what they had to do. I checked myself and they were right. It was not helpful. I donated the books. (My friend teaches math at an FCPS and suggested this series but it wasn’t good at all). |
I would like to see all the research showing kids learn more from random slide decks than textbooks. |
Is this possible? Years ago the choice was textbook, class, in person tutor or asking the teacher. Now, there are those things minus the book, plus: YouTube, websites, zoom 1:1 tutoring, Kahn Academy, group tutoring (in person and virtual), enriching supplementation. The only way to know this would be to test with and without textbooks back then. But I think it’s like a cooking- looking how to do a technique. Where do you go to learn the technique? Do you buy or borrow a book and follow the steps or do you Google it and watch a video? |
My kid is taking the PSAT today. No phones allowed, just graphing calculators. Same with the SAT next month. |
But the PSAT and SAT are changing soon to computer formats and will include a Desmos calculator. PSAT changes next fall and SAT in spring 2024, so current middle schoolers and 9th/10th graders should be fine just knowing Desmos: https://lhseleight.com/2022/04/17/college-board-makes-major-changes-to-sat/ |
Not all textbooks are created equal. Most K12 textbooks are boring and insipid. If you want a deep, high quality textbook, you have to do your research upfront. For example, you can rest assured that the AoPS Intermediate Algebra textbook has many, many problems which are more difficult and interesting than what is taught FCPS algebra 2 curriculum. They are also very well explained, showing multiple ways to think about the problem. It's a completely different ballgame from your average watered down textbook. You're still learning the same concepts and ideas, but far more effectively. |
We buy a textbook every year as it is extremely helpful to our child. We also do tutoring. The slide presentations don't work well for our child nor videos. |
Textbooks are good for learning the concept and then as a reference when kids forget one part of the procedure. It is painful watching kids replay an entire video, searching for the step they missed. If it's an equation on a whiteboard, they can fast forward, but if it's a technique that was discussed orally only, it's time consuming to find. Better to have an easy-to-access reference with an index. Also, textbooks have gone through vetting by many sets of eyes. Who knows how well reviewed Google entries or videos are and whether they have errors. |
Today's textbooks are a distracting mash-up of graphics, encouraging messages, and real-world applications. Older textbooks are better at laying out concepts and having tiered problems that steadily step up the level of rigor. AoPS is great for that too. |
Do you have a link to the textbook you are praising? |
Good point! Modern textbooks are incredibly distracting with all the graphics and information windows. The eye doesn’t know where to settle. Too much competing copy. As for Alg2, the teacher matters more than anything. My DD’s is HARD. Some of what she tests has not been covered in class. There is the expectation the students learn OUTSIDE of class. I think this is a new phenomenon that I don’t remember growing up |
You could just google 'aops intermediate algebra', but here ya go: https://artofproblemsolving.com/store/book/intermediate-algebra |
DP. AoPS is excellent but challenging. If your student has never done AoPS before, I'd also purchase the Introduction to Algebra textbook. They have great online courses too, but here again, you may want to enroll them in Intro to Algebra B first. AoPS posts their syllabi and pre-tests, post-tests for each course so you can get a better idea where your student is. AoPS is fantastic but a student could get discouraged if they are dropped into the desired course without the rigorous preparation AoPS assumes kids have when entering the course. That said, online AoPS is excellent. If your student does that, it won't really matter what is covered at school. https://artofproblemsolving.com/store https://artofproblemsolving.com/school/schedule A lesser time investment would be to go on Amazon and look for old used Algebra 2 textbooks (pre-2000) that do a good job of laying out content and providing rigorous problem step-up. |