Hiring manager and HR manager mixed messages after interview
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
I had a series of interviews today for a new job. At the end i met the hiring manager who said that everyone I met like me and that he would most probably to make an offer to me tomorrow.
In my wrap up session, I met again with the HR lead who said that the company would either drop me from the process or ask me to continue talking to them but they would speak to other candidates. He said the hiring manager's boss told him this. I was a bit taken aback but I suppose this trumps anything hiring manager said? I suppose I will know for sure in the next couple of days one way or another but isnt this a bit strange? |
Anonymous
|
I'd read it like the hiring manager really liked you (good!) and the hiring managers boss was sort of to be informed after and the hr manager was covering legal or other bases so you didn't think you had the job.
Just my two cents based off what you wrote... Good luck! |
Anonymous
| Thanks PP. OP here. I also had an interview with the hiring managers boss and he told me that his boss liked me. So i was bit surprised by the HR managers message that he ( the big boss) was on the fence about me and wouldnt make me an offer. |
Anonymous
|
I would put more stock in what the business person said over the HR person. I think in most companies that relationship is tighter.
Hoping something comes through for you! |
Anonymous
| I've had the interviewer tell me they'd decide in a couple weeks, only to be called with an offer 20 min later. |
Anonymous
Move on. You said the big boss said you'd either be dropped or kept warm while they interview others? The big boss didn't take to you. NBD. |
Anonymous
|
sounds totally inappropriate for the hiring manager to say that you'd most likely get an offer. i dont know anyone in HR who would say that without having checked with all the stakeholders and run background checks, called references, etc.
anyway, hope you get the job but I would stick with 'mixed messages' for now. |
Anonymous
|
Op here. Thanks everyone.
Normally i would assume that the "big boss" didnt like me as well but actually that interview went very well and he too (Big boss) gave me a lot of positive feedback. The hiring manager also said he spoke to BB and he liked me. The interview with the HR person on the other hand did not go well and i didnt get a good feeling about it. It was undoubtedly my worse interview with the entire group. His message about Big boss feedback was totally opposite to that of the hiring manager. TBH Im surprised that both of them said these things to me (apart from the fact that it was contradictory). Is this a bad sign overall re the company? |
Anonymous
| OP, this is why I despise HR. They get their noses into things that should be the business of the line people. Hope you get the offer! |
Anonymous
|
OP here. Silence from the company so its looks like the HR person was right.
Weird experience. Ah well |
Anonymous
| Is there something in your background that could be concerning to HR? And the other managers either didn't know or didn't care? |
Anonymous
| Not that I know of. |
Anonymous
|
OP here.
Just got a voicemail from the HR person asking me to call back in the next 30 mins or tomorrow for an update. I presume thats to tell me im in a process. But why call me after hours? |
Anonymous
Our HR folks tend to be in interviews all day long and often call/email at night when they have time and it's easier to reach ppl |
Anonymous
Really? Why not just wait until tomorrow in that case? I can understand if the call was at 6.30 but not at 9. |