Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Watch from 19:00 - 26:00. I'm no Jawando fan but he successfully forced slippery Damon Monteleone to admit what he wasn't trying to admit.
Why are MCPS officials like this? Why do they lie and hide and pretend so much?
What bothers me about this exchange is that Jawando in his story about the Principal who loved RJ was clearly talking about the impact of a restorative justice specialist. The county has I think 8 of these specially trained people who draw a full salary and usually split time at schools that most need them. There are many stories of the good these specialists achieve. This is NOT THE SAME as the RJ coaches. RJ coaches are school staff members who are minimally trained and given a stipend to be a RJ coach in addition to their usual job. RJ specialists and RJ coaches are not the same. I wish this was made clear in their conversation. A case could be made for cutting RJ coaches — the stipend positions- but keeping or even adding more RJ specialists.
Correct. Essie and Jawando were both fumbling and mixing up the Specialists versus the Coaches. Damon tried to correct him but it still came out confusing.
You're right that Jawando was talking about the impact and value of the specialist, not the coach. Frankly, I'd be surprised if the stipended coaches had any value at all. It's extra credit work that is going to be subject to a whole of variability in individual performance.[/quote
Overall, I wish MCPS had been more clear in naming these positions. If they had chosen to call Restorative Justice Specialists by that title, the other people should have been called something more like Assistant RJ coaches or something else to make clear this was a very different and very less trained position then an actual RJ specialist. Calling both positions by such a similar title was inevitably going to lead to confusion. Anyways, I think the stipend RJ coach positions are a waste of money at a time when cuts need to be made. But I think the RJ specialists have shown they can have a positive impact on the schools they serve so yes those 8 positions should be preserved or even expanded. And I wish Jawando had been listening well enough/ done his prep work better to understand these are two different types of positions or that Damon had offered a more basic and clear explanation so that the conversation around funding could have been less weird and unproductive.