Right, even if I agreed with you, how would SBOE control make this better? |
(and I should clarify that when I say “very well” that doesn’t mean easy. I know the first weeks of dealing with dysregulated kids who have not been in school was extremely hard. principals have so much on their plates. but we had to get the kids back and the reentry was only going to get harder the longer schools were closed. I’m glad the Mayor got more help to the schools in the form of covid coordinators. I’m ready to consider Wednesdays now too.) |
I also agree that things are going well in terms of Covid mitigation and think that people who think it isn't are increasingly living in some other world. That said, some of the things that people raise as issues don't have to do with covid -- regardless of whether HVACs are highly pertinent to reducing covid spread, we can agree that they are important for creating a better learning environment. The ineptitude that is pretty much always on display from DCPS (which may be deliberate slow-walking or might just be that THIS IS DC AND EVERYTHING ABOUT THE GOVERNMENT RUNS SLOWLY) could be helped with....maybe better quality people? Idk. If there's obvious LYING from the Chancellor, that's certainly not ok and undermines trust of parents in the district to provide education. That might be helped. |
I agree; I think Covid put a microscope on schools and the Mayor's impact on schools, at least for me. While a lot of the failures the PP wrote about have nothing to do with Covid, they're indicative of a poisoned system, top down. |
Right, I think some of the problems cited are not really about mitigating covid spread, they are about the rules that OSSE/DOH have imposed to mitigate spread, and the lack of resources to follow those rules. We might eventually agree that OSSE / DOH rules are unnecessary (hey if they aren't being followed because schools haven't been giving resources to follow them, and yet case rates are still low and falling, then why do we have them in the first place?), and that will solve the problems of following the rules. There are of course the people who are still very very very worried about covid (some with good reason, many not) and their worries may keep driving the difficult rules, etc. |
I disagree with your conclusion. I can get on board with certain increased oversight but I think dispersing control of schools would be far, far worse in terms of fixing the problems. |
The mayor opened the schools, they are open, covid cases are going down. I'm not sure where the evidence of "poisoned system" is. I could get into the argument that keeping the schools closed was actually the huge failure regarding schools but I actually don't want to get into the WTU-blaming cycle because it's a distraction. The schools had to be reopened (even if closure was justified) and she did it. |
What OSSE/DOH rules are you referring to? The quarantine rules? The definition of close contact? Those are ALL WORKING. The change that should be made is to allow test-to-stay instead of quarantining. A universal testing program may have some benefit in schools with outbreaks but that's going to need to be funded. The Council, if it actually cared, could have done that. |
I'm thinking about quarantine, and the issues around contact tracing, teaching kids who are quarantined (or not), what some want as a record of how many close contacts test positive, etc. We might find, for example, that quarantines aren't actually that useful in mitigating spread at schools (particularly under current conditions of falling-to-low community rates, low positivity rates in schools, etc.). Get rid of the quarantines related to close contacts of asymptomatic cases (and I'm not even talking about test-to-stay) and you get a reduction of kids that have to be followed, traced, etc. And before everyone calls me a Trumper who wants kids to die, there are recent studies finding the low rate of spread among asymptomatic schoolchildren, and schoolchildren who test positive even with symptoms. |
| To reiterate: If everyone is complaining that the rules aren't being followed and we still have low rates, maybe the rules aren't necessary. Or at least some of them. |
|
So it's either true that
1) the rules are being followed and they are leading to the low rates (in which case the complaints about test availability, HVAC, etc. are not true) OR 2) they aren't being followed (and the complaints about test availability, HVAC, etc. ARE true) but they don't matter |
THIS |
| There is no unbiased decision, objective views to be made as everyone works for the Mayor! |
The Council and the SBOE can't give objective views? |
I thought it was clear my point was that my issues with Mayoral Control have nothing to do with Covid. HVACs; Inequitable Modernizations; A racist evaluation system; inequitable distributions of funding; budget cuts in schools while central office balloons |