Jesus' Historicity

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Then next time say "general truth not necessarily responding to individual above: xxx x "

Or not. Not gives you more zinger targets.
Yippee Kay Yay....

Jesus historicists are reasonable people... NOT

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Then next time say "general truth not necessarily responding to individual above: xxx x "

Or not. Not gives you more zinger targets.
Yippee Kay Yay....

Jesus historicists are reasonable people... NOT

Thank you for sharing your views. Very useful in assessing the thread.
I am glad you enjoy spreading the news.
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Then next time say "general truth not necessarily responding to individual above: xxx x "

Or not. Not gives you more zinger targets.
Yippee Kay Yay....

You failed at your reading comprehension so the solution is to demand that others cater to your lack of understanding?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Then next time say "general truth not necessarily responding to individual above: xxx x "

Or not. Not gives you more zinger targets.
Yippee Kay Yay....

Jesus historicists are reasonable people... NOT

Thank you for sharing your views. Very useful in assessing the thread.
I am glad you enjoy spreading the news.
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

This isn't the gospels. It's not about "spreading the news" as Christians like to do. It is to have a discussion on whether a real person existed that formed the basis of "Jesus Christ".

When assessing the thread, use your own judgement instead of relying on the views of others.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:With his alleged birthday coming up, let's discuss the person that is being celebrated. Present your information and argument for Jesus, fact or fiction.

Jesus was made up -- not of whole cloth, because a messiah was predicted. But those were the olden days, before modern science and running water and a bunch of stuff that we now take for granted.

Kids can't imagine life without the internet. Neither can I! Remember those old movies where people would wait impatiently for the mailman to come?

No he was not made up. His existence and the words he spoke have been proven. What is likely made up is that he was the son of God. Probably not. Then again, how did such an extraordinary person come to have such extraordinary advice on how to be a good person?

In any event he was an amazing man and if we all followed his teachings the world would be a better place.

is he really any more extraordinary than Confucius or Gautam Buddh, Socrates, plato etc..?? I dont really think so- the same sort of beliefs pop up in many cultures around the world. he just lived in relatively recent times but not too recent like Muhammad/Baba Nanak. what I find remarkable is that one hand he is supposed to be a Jewish messiah but his message is SO Radically different- its universal, its kind and just based on character versus race, God is loving and generous and that is antithetical to the harsh cultures, both Roman and Jewish, that he preached in and that gave rise to the global force that is Christianity.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:With his alleged birthday coming up, let's discuss the person that is being celebrated. Present your information and argument for Jesus, fact or fiction.

Jesus was made up -- not of whole cloth, because a messiah was predicted. But those were the olden days, before modern science and running water and a bunch of stuff that we now take for granted.

Kids can't imagine life without the internet. Neither can I! Remember those old movies where people would wait impatiently for the mailman to come?

No he was not made up. His existence and the words he spoke have been proven. What is likely made up is that he was the son of God. Probably not. Then again, how did such an extraordinary person come to have such extraordinary advice on how to be a good person?

In any event he was an amazing man and if we all followed his teachings the world would be a better place.

is he really any more extraordinary than Confucius or Gautam Buddh, Socrates, plato etc..?? I dont really think so- the same sort of beliefs pop up in many cultures around the world. he just lived in relatively recent times but not too recent like Muhammad/Baba Nanak. what I find remarkable is that one hand he is supposed to be a Jewish messiah but his message is SO Radically different- its universal, its kind and just based on character versus race, God is loving and generous and that is antithetical to the harsh cultures, both Roman and Jewish, that he preached in and that gave rise to the global force that is Christianity.

FFS. Read the thread BEFORE making inane posts.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:With his alleged birthday coming up, let's discuss the person that is being celebrated. Present your information and argument for Jesus, fact or fiction.

Jesus was made up -- not of whole cloth, because a messiah was predicted. But those were the olden days, before modern science and running water and a bunch of stuff that we now take for granted.

Kids can't imagine life without the internet. Neither can I! Remember those old movies where people would wait impatiently for the mailman to come?

No he was not made up. His existence and the words he spoke have been proven. What is likely made up is that he was the son of God. Probably not. Then again, how did such an extraordinary person come to have such extraordinary advice on how to be a good person?

In any event he was an amazing man and if we all followed his teachings the world would be a better place.

is he really any more extraordinary than Confucius or Gautam Buddh, Socrates, plato etc..?? I dont really think so- the same sort of beliefs pop up in many cultures around the world. he just lived in relatively recent times but not too recent like Muhammad/Baba Nanak. what I find remarkable is that one hand he is supposed to be a Jewish messiah but his message is SO Radically different- its universal, its kind and just based on character versus race, God is loving and generous and that is antithetical to the harsh cultures, both Roman and Jewish, that he preached in and that gave rise to the global force that is Christianity.

FFS. Read the thread BEFORE making inane posts.

I don't think pp's post is inane.

[Anonymous]

There’s no proof, no evidence. If you are wondering how tons of people started fabricating stories about a person that never existed, or if he did, was not anything more than a poor man who had some radical things to say, I will first refer you to the childhood game of telephone. Remember in those days people died young: 40-80 years might seem like a short time, but that could be 2-3 generations of oral traditions getting progressively larger and more embellished. Plenty of time to turn a broke bastard (in the actual sense, no judgment) into a miracle working son of God.

And then you can look at more modern examples where people invented religions out of whole cloth, like Mormonism and Scientology, and just how quickly people latched on.

It’s called faith for a reason - you have no proof and are being asked to believe anyway. The most credible stories have elements of truth. Historians really do think there was a great flood in the Middle East based on how many different cultures have myths surrounding it. But did Noah fill an ark with two of every species? No. That’s a story to explain why people survived despite a great flood. Other cultures have other stories.

[Anonymous]

Polynesian and Micronesian oral traditions have flood/deluge stories.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Polynesian and Micronesian oral traditions have flood/deluge stories.

Not surprising. Seems like everyone has a flood story.

[Anonymous]

In all due respect to some wonderful Mormon people I have met, it seems far fetched that outside of Palmyra, NY an angel gave Joseph Smith tablets.

OT: I have a very hard time believing that someone named Jesus did not walk the face the earth and preach. Also have a very hard time believing that everything on earth just came about without any supernatural guidance. Is the one god? Is Jesus the son of God? Nobody can 100% answer that, but some force had to be at work.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The gospels allegorized a historical Jesus.

Anonymous authors writing 100s of miles away in another language... rrrriiiiiggghhhhtttt 🙄

Where did the gospel writers come from? Where did they live and travel? I thought they traveled around Israel.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:In all due respect to some wonderful Mormon people I have met, it seems far fetched that outside of Palmyra, NY an angel gave Joseph Smith tablets.

OT: I have a very hard time believing that someone named Jesus did not walk the face the earth and preach. Also have a very hard time believing that everything on earth just came about without any supernatural guidance. Is the one god? Is Jesus the son of God? Nobody can 100% answer that, but some force had to be at work.

Why did any force, besides natural ones, have to be at work? No reason at all.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:In all due respect to some wonderful Mormon people I have met, it seems far fetched that outside of Palmyra, NY an angel gave Joseph Smith tablets.

OT: I have a very hard time believing that someone named Jesus did not walk the face the earth and preach. Also have a very hard time believing that everything on earth just came about without any supernatural guidance. Is the one god? Is Jesus the son of God? Nobody can 100% answer that, but some force had to be at work.

Why does it seem "far-fetched" to you? Because Palmyra is close by and not far, far away in Israel? Jesus is no more believable than the Angel Moroni.

Obviously, only natural forces were at work. The other stuff is made-up stories from before humans knew about science.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:In all due respect to some wonderful Mormon people I have met, it seems far fetched that outside of Palmyra, NY an angel gave Joseph Smith tablets.

OT: I have a very hard time believing that someone named Jesus did not walk the face the earth and preach. Also have a very hard time believing that everything on earth just came about without any supernatural guidance. Is the one god? Is Jesus the son of God? Nobody can 100% answer that, but some force had to be at work.

Why do you have a hard time accepting that there was no Jesus?

Have you read through the information in this very thread? Lots of explanations already provided.

Also, do you not see the connection = you find Mormonism BS, but you don't see the same parallel to Christianity.