
I don’t know what her particular comment is about, but BLM has in the past tied Israel to racism and colonialism in the Soviet-style way that all Marxist movements reduce and distort. There is also a strong vein of scapegoating Jews in Black nationalist movements. And finally, the language of demonization for "privilege," "proportion," and "hidden power" that informs a lot of BLM rhetoric is scarily compatible with the vocabulary of old-fashioned antisemitism. It has been very easy for too many people who support BLM to make that leap. |
It looks like only 2 factions did, and the BLM National organization commented that it is distinct from these factions. So if BLM claims to be for human rights, they have to fight for everyone's human rights? Was Israel supporting BLM when they were fighting for black lives in America? I agree with the hypocrisy part of the factions that supported Hamas or inferred support fir Hamas after the massacre last week. But I don't get the rest. BLM seems to be focused on supporting the rights of black people in America. I don't see why they should be expected to support Israel. They do not support African groups either. |
Absolutely. Here’s an image for the “Israel is a colonizer” people: Jews sang Hatikvah (hope) when the Allies liberated us. We dreamt of being free in our homeland. Not of going back to Poland or Germany, but of finally going back to our homeland. But sure — we are imperial colonizers. Here’s a video of a ship of Holocaust survivors in 1945, singing Hatikvah and raising up the Israeli flag. https://youtu.be/171nZBA3eTc?si=fwsXsTHpuabfmXJG |
The homeland where you lived 2000 years ago? So if a Native American pulls you out of your house in the middle of the night and tells you to leave because his tribe once lived there would you happily oblige and pack up and go to Mexico? |
Jews have lived in what is now Israel since it was the Kingdoms of Judea and Israel. Continuously. Yes in smaller numbers due to multiple genocides, but we have always been there. 500,000 Jews lived in Mandatory Palestine in 1945. So your analogy is deeply flawed. But really, I am shocked at your callousness towards a ship of stateless Holocaust survivors wanting to join their people in Mandatory Palestine and be free. |
One of the dumbest posts I’ve seen recently. |
Nearly 80 years ago. Let's talk about now and what the Israeli government is doing now and has been doing. You want to know why some BLM groups are critical of Israel it's because of how the government has treated Ethiopians- Ethiopian Jews returning to what they consider their homeland. Look into those human rights violations. Calling for the murder of Jews is wrong. Hamas murdering civilians is wrong. It's also wrong when the Israeli government commits human rights abuses and we can't keep excusing it or overlooking it because of what happened to us 80 years ago. |
Show me where BLM is purely just advocating for Ethiopian Jews (who occupy leadership positions in the Israeli government) and aren’t calling for the eradication of Israel. |
You might fall over from patting your own back so hard |
She doesn’t even realize the Jews were given what is essentially a reservation. The only difference is, Americans here aren’t attacking reservations from all sides |
+2 |
It has been asked before, but I ask again: where is the outrage at Hamas firing rockets into Israel’s civilian areas?
And no, b-b-but Iron Dome is not a morally correct answer. The bias against Israel is abhorrent. |
Yup. The Brits gave Jews that land because they were the ones who owned it. What’s happening now is like Native American tribes fighting over land, not like the Brits fighting indigenous people. And before you say “well but Israel is backed by the US,” remember Hamas gets $100 million/year just from Iran. Both sides have their benefactors. |
Yep. The number of rockets I’ve seen in the last 2 weeks since the war started is 7,300. All aimed squarely at civilian targets. |
Yes when you want to live in denial, the truth always sounds dumb. Not my fault if you don’t want to acknowledge history as it happened. Yes there were Jews in Palestine prior to 1947 but the majority of the population was comprised of Palestinians. That is why the Nakba happened where Palestinians were kicked out of their homes and forced to be refugees in neighboring countries. The audacity of you guys to insist that land belongs to you. It all comes down to religion for you because you think you are the chosen people and that is why this land belongs to you because your God ordained so and if other people are kicked out and forced to be refugees then so be it. |