Who makes a tasty, but inexpensive b-day cake?

[Anonymous]

Which one have you tried and liked/disliked?

Harris Teeter
Giant
Safeway
Sam's Club

Looking for yellow with chocolate icing

[Anonymous]

Costco is better than all of those.

[Anonymous]

agreed. costco if you have a friend with a membership!

[Anonymous]

I think that Sam's Club and Giant make good cakes, but would always go for Costco over either of them.

[Anonymous]

I love a Safeway sheet cake -- yum. And cheap.

[Anonymous]

OK, I have to chime in because I seem to be one of the few that hates Costco cake.

I like Safeway the best.

[Anonymous]

Costco cakes are NASTY. Both Giant and Safeway have been fine.

[Anonymous]

Costco is consistantly better in my book. Especially if you prefer buttercream over whipped cream icing.

[Anonymous]

I also think Costco cakes are nasty. And I've never had a grocery store sheetcake that I've liked.

[Anonymous]

Just had a Harris Teeter one (Thomas) and didn't think it was worth the cost at all! Should have gone for Giant - same thing but a lot cheaper, I think.

[Anonymous]

Costco, hands down.

[Anonymous]

Safeway.

[Anonymous]

I wanted to add one that you did not mention on your list - Wegmans make a great cake and I thought it was reasonable pricing. Just wanted to throw in one more option.

[Anonymous]

Giant!!!

[Anonymous]

Giant has consistently received only favorable raves and compliments over the years at my celebrations!