This turned my DS off to Notre Dame. Not saying it's bad, just wasn't for my kid. Decided to attend somewhere else with a Greek System he is thriving in. |
Fair point. I think the student’s frame of reference matters. UVA is much smaller than Cal/UCLA, and felt more accessible I terms of resources and social opportunites. If we are rolling g strictly private here, why is Brown not getting more airtime? It’s where son’s bf went and that kid loved the social life. But he was a recruited athlete. |
Interesting. I’ve heard somewhat negative things about Brown’s social climate in the last two years. It’s become nerdier and quirky (in a non-social way). |
| At Amherst, clubs are open to everyone—so much easier and less-stressful getting involved and making friends as compared with what we hear about schools where everything is a competition get in |
I think most smart people recognize that there are social kids and anti-social kids everywhere. Your kid will definitely find people to go out with outside of the 8 or so schools listed on this thread. You don't think the posts here can be biased in any way? |
The downside of clubs being open to everyone is that they're open to everyone. I can't count how many organizations I've been part of that have been ruined by one or two [I won't use the term that comes to mind because every post in this thread using that term has been deleted, but it starts with a c and rhymes with thuds]. On the other hand, I agree the hyper-competitive club culture at schools like UPenn is out of control. |
Some of us are smart enough to filter through. Sure, there may be social kids everywhere, but the "vibe" might not be conducive to that culture. You know? Or maybe, you don't. |
Yes, I don’t know and no one will really know until you’re a student on campus. Seriously, did you even go to college? Don’t make decisions based on what strangers tell you on an anonymous board. You can go and try to feel the “vibe” yourself and even then there are so many other factors that play into the experience. |
Also, 40% identify as LBTQ+ which gives the social climate an entirely different vibe. |
| Georgetown has houses (not residential houses, greek-style houses). None are affiliated, but they are at the center of the party culture. |
Some schools are looking for the kids who are social and outgoing....captains of teams and presidents of student govt.....Vanderbilt comes to mind. Same with UMichigan......and now Northwestern/Notre Dame. |
My DC attends a Jesuit high school and Notre Dame did not have the same feel at all. Jesuits are pretty liberal. The vibe at Notre Dame felt very conservative and religious. There is not anything wrong with this, but I wouldn’t describe Notre Dame is a school that is in the Jesuit model. It is absolutely 100% into community service, as are all Catholic schools. |
Not Northwestern in 2026. Maybe in 1996. |
I think ALL top schools are looking for these kinds of kids -- kids who will contribute to campus life. |
I think this is true, as a Vandy parent. My own kid is high stats, authentically pointy, AND an extroverted partier. Most of his social circles are somewhat similar. That said, when I am on campus I cannot help but notice a large contingent of females who strike me as much more studious. They’ll be walking down Greek row at 8 on a Friday in groups of 2-3 coming from class/library/dining wearing giant backpacks |