|
I see it more as the land of self soothing… convincing yourself that if a kid is high achieving, they must have no life. To the contrary, I think you’ll more frequently find that the highest achievers are high achievers in more than just school or test taking. Many are star athletes, or accomplished musicians, or more. |
Thanks for spelling it out. At the lower percentile levels you have to make this stuff very explicit. |
Very similar here. DD scored 97% and we applied for 5 schools - she got into the 3 less competitive ones. She plays sports but is not exceptional. She’s an exceptional writer and published, but that wasn’t good enough. |
Yes and many of those are children of high profile people or are exceptional in a domain that the school cares about. |
I see what you did there. |
So many here with high scores saying they did not get admitted to top schools. |
I think the problem is that many kids have high scores, so many kids both that get in and that don't get in have high scores. |
I wonder what percentage of kids are 99th percentile or above. If only they would make that clear. |
LOL! The thing is, around here it is much higher than 1%. |
Lots of top 1 percenters in the DMV privates. Scores skew much higher here than say, if you were in Mississippi or Wyoming. |
Yes but vast majority of test takers are in hot private school markets. I wonder how they norm the results. I suspect they don’t norm at all though, it’s too hard a problem and there’s no right way to do it. |
I think the 1% is nothing in comparison to the 0.1% rich, VIP, double ivy legacies here. The school has so many choices. So the test score doesn't matter at the end. The social order is really decided before the child is born. For those who don't get int a top school, they just have to enjoy it and be aware life is unfair. |