Ah, puerile name calling and ad hominem attack. Always the best way to strengthen an argument. People assert themselves for their own benefit all the time. “Excuse me, I believe I was before you in line.” Why should a person with a life-threatening allergy be expected to remain silent because many, even most, people think of peanuts as a tasty, filling, low carb snack? The people we’ve occasionally asked for an accommodation have always been very gracious. |
What is the peanut-contaminated item? If the "peanut-contaminated" item is a trashcan where someone might have thrown out the remnant of their peanut butter sandwich, seems kind of anxiety driven. If it's a plate smeared with peanut butter and it's a young child who doesn't have a lot of awareness yet, makes more sense. People can be very bad at risk assessment. I guarantee your kid does a bunch of things daily that are a lot more risky than being around a trash can with a peanut butter sandwich in it. |
You can definitely do that. The point is that will not exert perfect control over your environment, which is clearly what you are after. I think the reason you could be expected to remain silent is because a person several seats away from you minding their own business and eating something of their choosing is not affecting you at all, despite what you have convinced yourself. Unless they are a toddler and about to smear it near your kid or approach your child directly, approaching adults eating food and telling them to stop is obnoxious. |
I don’t think it is “anxiety driven” for a person with a life threaten allergy to want to avoid accidentally getting contaminated and then transferring the contamination to where they might ingest it. Because people touch their mouths, etc., and don’t always surgery-scrub beforehand. That other life risks exist is irrelevant. One avoids what one reasonably can. What would be your view if the concern was a chemical that might find its way somewhere, as in the case where somebody carelessly threw a rag soaked with turpentine or anotherindustrial solvent into a trash can? |
Somebody several seats or tables away in a lunchroom is worlds different than one row ahead on a sardine can economy class airline who is actually aerosolizing their food while they eat it. And “obnoxious” is a far better label than “victim.” |
I get it if your kid has a severe allergy, but I don't view mine as a severe (at least based on what our allergist has said, lack of accidental exposures, freely eating out at restaurants, etc.) I will be more vigilant and carry the epi-pens, but I'm not planning on going overboard like making people around me stop eating peanuts. My kid knows to be careful. |
Thank you! Do you know if she can eat more than she used to pre-OIT, or did she complete revert back? |
Phew, it’s a relief to see you know the difference, but also confusing. If you do know the difference, then why when PP clearly wrote that she “ASKED” someone not to eat a product containing peanuts did you accuse her of “TELLING” strangers not to eat something. Can you answer that question? |
Just a FYI, my daughter had a severe reaction to first ingestion of egg which is supposedly unlikely. It required an epi and ambulance ride. Our allergist encouraged us to NOT fry or cook eggs unless we had her in both an a) separate room and b) well ventilation either direct vent from stove to outside or windows open in the kitchen because egg protein can aerosol. Typically, unpredictable, does not usually are the key words in the FACT you listed above. The reason for the hyper vigilance in planes is because you are in the air away from medical care. Not the PP but I would think as an allergy parent yourself you would know that there are a range of severities and would also, god forbid, your child be on the severe range, take every precaution and ALSO not want them limited because of peoples inability to stop eating for X hours while in flight where medical care is not available. And I promise you that the hyper vigilant mom is also doing everything in their control- wiping, etc- along with educating their child on how to protect themselves. A little grace goes a long way. |
some of you are lol insufferable you can't have any friends in your real life or if you think they do they hate you |
DD (now nearly 6) started OIT for cashews at around 2.5. The first 6 months or so, we had to go in every month or so. She does a skin test and bloodwork yearly. Her allergy level (as reflected in the bloodwork) has considerably decreased (she’s supposed to eat four cashews daily) but I always carry her EpiPen. They don’t take up that much space. |
I'm genuinely curious if there is any case on record of a person having an allergic reaction based on a nearby plane passenger eating peanuts. I have an allergic kid. This never crossed my mind to worry about this. |
LOL, OK. So your kid has been making sure to have an epi-pen kit with her at play dates, takes it to every restaurant, and talks to servers and restaurant managers about her allergy? Wow. Impressive! At such a young age. It’s also amazing that your kid understands that even mild allergies can become severe with no warning, especially when there are exposures over time. It’s wonderful that she realizes that even though she has not had a severe reaction as of yet, it could be a severe reaction at any time. Interesting that she knows that when you didn’t seem to know that. |
Doesn’t fully answer your question but read on: https://simpleflying.com/delta-air-lines-passenger-removed-flight-shellfish-allergy/ |
I agree with this. The part I don't agree with is the assessment that someone throwing their peanut butter sandwich in a trash can could somehow transfer to you (or your kid) and you might ingest it. To give the benefit of the doubt, you are envisioning a world where the peanut butter is dragged down the inside of the trashcan and then you (or your kid) subsequently touch or hold onto that same side of the trashcan. That's the scenario? I'm just not operating in that head space that I think that is happening. I can't really respond to equating a peanut butter sandwich to a turpentine soaked rag. |