Sounds like a massive case of sour grapes, pp. All the information about such competitions are online. Your kid can google this information or google porn sites. The amount of screen time that low performing kids spend time on is mindboggling. But they are watching Tiktok, WAP, twerking and other relevant info about the topics they are interested in. A whole lot of students from some typical community did not place first, but they too worked hard and participated. They did not have a defeatist attitude. It is so sad that the kids become as good or bad as their parents. Unless there is a license requirement for people to have kids, we will keep having poor quality parents have low performing kids. Then these kids will suffer because what the hell can their parents offer them but obesity? Maybe the schools should foster these children? How else can you make up for poor parenting and poor home life? Maybe the poor kids need Tiger parents. |
oh well, then next time a white student whose parents are lawyers wins a prize in writing, then we should question whether they deserve it, yes? Or how about the legacy kids of mostly white parents who get into ivies? Why aren't you questioning their parents' professions? After all, that elite institution seems to be the ultimate prize for so many people, of all races, especially legacy white families. |
|
As was explained earlier in the thread, the competition winners had mentorship from scientists and access to elite labs. The same is true for the old famous intel and Siemens high school competition. An “average”kid who has a great idea and tinkers in their kitchen or garage has very little shot. You need contacts, you need time and money for transportation.
It’s not just a matter of only needing google. |
Most. I'm sure these are smart kids, but let's get real here. |
oh, you mean like rich white kids who get into UPenn? |
Well, there are other venues for the average kid tinkering in his kitchen and garage. There is social media now that talented people can showcase their talent. BUT, loser are gonna blame others.
The average kid should consider himself lucky if he has atleast finished Algebra 2 in HS. The bar is pretty low for them and they will get a medal for participation. Never hear an average Asian kid complaining, but the non-Asians have excuses for everything. |
Wow! They are able to fool all the people who run the competitions but you figured it out. 3 M actually assigns mentors to these kids once they submit their ideas and pass a few hurdles. There is extensive interviewing to determine that the idea can be useful, is original, can be translated into a prototype. The parents are not working with scientists. The kids are working with scientists once they make it to the final rounds. But, of course, little snowflake Coltan cannot do that kind of work because he has anxiety, peanut allergy and is also dating the hot cheerleader. |
| Wonderful accompalishment by this kid. Of course, the fact that many jealous people gets triggered by her success makes it even more wonderful. |
| The title is “ Americas top young scientist” not “ UMC kid with the most connected parents”. The barrier for entry and success should be equally accessible to every kid in America with the inherent natural intelligence and interest. |
It sure looks like that even among the UMC and rich kids with the most connected parents, its the Asian American kids who have the inherent natural intelligence and interest in STEM subjects. Why is that? For the rest of the kids, we all know that the barrier to entry and success in their life and this competition remains their parents, their community and their culture. |
Well said. Love all the negativity and 'toxic' attitudes by envious parents. I thought only Asians were toxic? I guess white parents can be just as toxic if not more. Try to come up with something better to knock the young kid. |
Because they cheat at fake ADHD diagnosis, WISC testing, college admissions and SAT exams, they engage in 'projection' and accuse Asian parents of cheating. |
+1 |
Didn't know this was limited to one racial group? |
| When my kids were participating in science fairs, the winners' projects were often highly correlated with their parents' professions. |