The people I know who did it had kids who missed the cut off by a week and had the support of the Preschool Teachers. I know that our Preschool Teachers were pretty honest with parents about the kids readiness for K. We had a few kids who were held by a year because they were not ready, they were struggling with the structure and schedule of Preschool, K would have been really, really hard for them. A few were October babies and the Preschool Teachers thought that another year of Preschool would have been boring for the kids, they were ready for K. Both of those kids were also bigger for their age and were starting to read. One went to private K and moved to FCPS for first grade. The other went to a Parochial school for K with the intention of moving to FCPS but the family stayed in Parochial. Both are doing just fine. The kids who were red-shirted still have a few struggles in ES. They are good kids but just on the more inattentive, immature side of things.
I don't know anyone who did this past a November birthday and the kids re still in ES so we will see how it ends up but, so far, the choice made sense. |
I teach kindergarten and my October and November kiddos are just fine where they are and I think it’s good to be older and more mature. I actually wish the cut off was before school started so we didn’t have kids turning 5 in September with already turned 6 year olds. I have a September birthday teen and sometimes regret not waiting a year.
|
I think you are misunderstanding. They are saying for K, if you come after the start of the school year (ie. Oct-June) of that specific school year. It does not dictate what happens the next school year for 1st grade. So a child could complete K at a private school. And then enroll in first grade the following year in FCPS. They would not be required to take K again because the child would already be 6 at that point. |
Sorry, misspoke. The child entering 1st wouldn’t turn 6 until possibly Oct-Dec. The rule above is only for “entering Kindergarten.” It prevents people from starting at a private early for K and transferring in the middle of the year to K in FCPS. Those kids wouldn’t be allowed to enter K in the middle of the year even though they would be 5 already at that point. The next year is a brand new year. There is not a rule about entering 1st grade. If a child completed K somewhere else, they would not repeat K unless a parent wanted them to. In that case they would still follow the rules. A child “may” enter K if they turn 5 before the cut off. The rule doesn’t state they “have” to go into K. Especially if child already completed K elsewhere. The child would be enrolled in 1st. |
No, the child who has a birthday in Oct and went for a year of private k would be placed in kindergarten. They are 5 years old and would not be turning 6 until after September 30. The possible placement into Grade 1 would occur for a child who was eligible for kindergarten but whose parents choose to keep them at home or enroll elsewhere. The child would be turning 6 sometime that year that they are not in FCPS. When the parent came to enroll the child, the school could determine that they should go to kindergarten or to place them in Grade 1. |
If the parents have documentation that the child completed K, the child would be placed in first grade. I have seen it happen. None of my friends with an October birthday who went the private K route had any issues with being placed in First Grade the following year in FCPS. If this is happening then it is new in the last 3 years. |
+1 |
Sorry this is 100% incorrect. |
This doesn’t make sense. FCPS would allow a child who stayed home and did not attend K to enter first grade early?w |
The age and date cutoff applies to kindergarten, not first grade. So you can’t enter kindergarten before the age cutoff but can enter first without regard to age. |
This. By your mistaken logic, you’d have a 6th grader who went to private school at a place that allowed her to start kindergarten at 4.5 years old (when FCPS would have denied her admission), and wanted to transfer into FCPS as a 2nd, 4th or 6th grader, she’d have to go back and repeat the year before. Ridiculous, right? The language you’re quoting prevents a kid who started kindergarten elsewhere before the age of 5 and wants to transfer into FCPS while still in that same kindergarten year. This will not be allowed. |
These kids are not 4.5, and most are turning 5 in September and October. If you transfer in at a later grade its not an issue. Spoken from someone who has done it. They probably will not allow a mid-year in K or possibly 1st, but after 2-3-4-5-6th, they legally cannot force you to hold your child back if your child passed the previous year. |
Former FCPS teacher: any child who has completed a grade elsewhere will be able to transfer in to the next grade in FCPS. Admin may try to advise you to consider holding the child back a year, depending on the circumstances. PA has places that allow it at 4 years and 7 months. |
We were pushed to hold back, I said no as child had top scores and they had to agree as there was no good reason to hold back. 4.7 is very rare. |
5 by 12/1 - NY
5 by 10/15 - ME Montana allows for case by case exceptions. CT - 4 years and 8 months |