This is one of the grossest things I have ever read here, which is impressive. |
It's comments like the ones you're responding to that make these complaints hard to take seriously. We have data; we know what "most men" do. They don't come home and do "nothing" they come home and do less, but they also work more. The issue, if there is one, is about distribution, not that either party is doing "nothing." Overall, we're all doing about the same amount. |
So...if some people of X group do Y, then I should just sit back and take it when people accuse me of doing Y because I belong to X group? Do you hear yourself? |
Oh please, there was an entire thread the other day about how a SAHM should consider her husband's successes her own. People post glowing things about SAHMs (including on this very thread!) all the time. |
So don't make the dinner. Don't change the bed sheets. Don't clean the house. If YOU want it done, do it. If you don't care, then don't. It's really not that complicated. |
No, her mistakes was taking on a task she didn't want to do. DH: Can my mom come stay with us next weekend? DW: Sure thing, that'll be nice. That's it. That's all you have to do. Let your husband, his mother's son, figure out what needs to be done for his mom to come visit. By playing into this whole woe is me I have to make fresh meatballs stereotype you're just enabling, and probably raising, another generation of useless men. |
So to be clear, the options are: (1) Make dinner, change the sheets, and clean the house yourself. (2) Greet a houseguest with a dirty house, dirty sheets, and no food. Okay, what if the houseguest is a mutual college friend of both people. So if the wife thinks they should do some basic stuff to prepare for the guest, because it's just good manners and will also help the visit to go better, but the husband doesnt care, again, her choice is to do it all her self or just treat the houseguest (who is equally a guest of both partner) poorly? It just doesn't make sense to run a marriage this way. It would be one thing if we were talking about one partner wanting to just change the sheets and order a pizza, and the other is like "no we have to clean the house top to bottom and make a 5 course meal, nothing else will do." That would be an example of one partner having unreasonably high standards and needing to either do the extra work she's created herself or accept the bare minimum that her partner is advocating for (or even better, have a productive conversation and meet somewhere in the middle). But we're talking about situations where a wife is advocating for the bare minimum and the husband is like "I simply do not care about incredibly basic home care, hosting, or hygiene, if you want that stuff done do it yourself." This is such childish, petulant BS I simply cannot believe anyone would advocate for it. You can't discuss a meal a few days in advance to ensure you don't have to cook or come up with something last minute when you own mother is coming to visit? What kind of idiot, irresponsible, man child nonsense is that? You can't take 5 minutes to change some sheets or just make sure the guest bathroom is presentable? For your own mother? Again, this is such bare minimum stuff. What is really happening is that the men in these scenarios KNOW they are fighting against doing the bare minimum, but they are depending on the fact that society judges women much more harshly for this stuff than men (and will blame the wife for a messy house or no dinner even when it's his mom who's coming to visit) to incentivize his wife to just go ahead and do it. So... dad privilege. |
I agree with the bolded but not the rest of it. Why can't the answer be that the solution is rely on both parents TO RAISE THE CHILDREN THEY BOTH MADE? |
Agreed but I actually appreciate the PPs example because it highlights how lopsided this conversation is. We talk about how women have to/get to choose whether or not to stay home with kids, but realistically they can only do that if their partners make enough on their own to support the family. Most don't. If people are going to go around telling women they should be home with their children for at least the first 5 years of life (something plenty of conservatives will argue for), why isn't it okay to tell men "you need to make more money so your wives can afford to stay home with the kids"? People (men) freak out when you imply that men need to do a better job of providing financially for a family, but people tell women all the time they need to take better care of their kids. It's a double standard. I personally agree with you that really couples should just view the whole enchilada (the money, the childcare, the home care, the household planning) as their joint responsibility and allocate it as equally as possible, whether they divide and conquer (one person works for money, the other takes care of the kids) or they split it all down the middle, or some other arrangement that is equitable. But it's worth pointing out that the same people who demand women stay home and care for the kids are not also telling men to facilitate that by earning more (probably because the same people also tend to be anti-worker and pro-corporation and don't want workers getting any ideas about asking for higher pay). It's a fair point. |
Hmm, I get what the list is getting at. However, in our household, we divide stuff up. For example, I have not cooked a dinner in years, or chaperoned a field trip ever. But my husband has not planned a birthday party, or replaced outgrown clothing. |
Look, you are so far out of the realm of normal, basic functioning family life that it’s almost pointless. In normal families you do normal things, like put a hot meal on the table when Grandma comes to visit. Dad privilege is assuming Mom will take care of it. Personality disorder is trashing your wife for *wanting to make YOUR mom a hot meal*, and claiming that it’s totally made up work and she’s an idiot for having such high standards. |
No, we have data showing that men increase women’s domestic labor. Also it’s well known that men hide at work to avoid coming home to take care of kids. |
+100. Any decent man would perceive that his wife wanting to make his *own mother’s* visit nicer is a valuable gesture that benefits the whole family. It’s just mind boggling to claim otherwise. I do think there are some men who honestly would treat their own mothers that way (dirty house, no food). |
1) We most certainly do have data showing that between paid work, household work, and caregiving men and women do similar amounts of work in a week. You might not like it, but you can just say "no." 2) We do have data that women in married households do more household work than women in other types of households. Some other data showed men doing less, but there's also data that shows that married men do more household work than single men. The 2022 ATUS data showed men doing a bit over 30 minutes more of household activity per day if they were married and living with their spouse than if they were single (or married but living apart from their spouse). Would you call that "data that women increase men's domestic labor"? 3) I know nothing about men hiding at work to avoid coming home to kids. I don't do it, I don't know a man who does it (all the dads at my office check out early to take do school pick up, actually, but it's a small office). I do think it's funny, though, that time use data about women's housework and childcare is reliable, but the same data about men doing paid labor isn't. Convenient. |
So did none of this behavior show itself before you had kids? My husband and I each had a dog when we started dating, so I was aware of how much effort he would put into taking care of an animal. We went on trips together, so I saw how much time he would be willing to spend researching trips with me. We hosted parties, so I could tell how much help he would provide if we did something like that, including if it was for "my" friends. We spent time with family, so I knew how much he would be responsible for in terms of responsibility for things related to gifts/planning/hosting/etc. What exactly did you do when you were dating? |