What about all the juvenile crime ? Are those kids allowed in the shelter? |
Not true - housing values are generally depressed around DC's public housing in every direction for a several-block radius, as an example of where that idea's wrong. And if you saw the behavior of some of the kids, for example on metrobus to go to school, you'd be shocked. Rude, nasty, fighting, shouting disrespectfully at the driver for no good reason - and not a damned one seems to manage to use their free bus pass as they are supposed to. Not to mention the shoplifting at the stores. CVS and other stores will often post someone at the door and only let one of them in at a time because the shoplifting is so bad. |
Statistics don't lie. Children in these situations often have behavioral issues and other learning issues and how can a school that is trying to create a community that is stable achieve that when children are coming in and out of the classroom all year for just months at a time and these children need extra help in getting adjusted to the curriculum? Property values will go down because one- people are concerned about living near a shelter and for two - if people know 40 families will be in and out every 2-3 months at their public school, they may not buy in that neighborhood. Schools are the first thing many people in NWDC look at unless they are going private. |
| The person claiming it's all red herrings and that there will be no problems probably lives in a neighborhood far removed from any shelters or low income housing. I have zero doubt of that, because I personally see things on a nearly daily basis that strongly disagrees with the PP's suggestion that there will be no problems. |
Babies and toddlers don't attend elementary school. Google Laura Zelinger. You guys have the former head of the USICH on your team...she's implementing the right models based on best practices. I know this is new and scary, but it works. You can't compare a brand new 40 unit family shelter to anything that currently exists in DC. |
What formula do you propose for reimbursement with respect to children impacted in the schools? What metrics are to be used? Sigh. |
Well, apparently Ward 5/6 AA residents can be as afraid as Ward 2/3 white ones. Apparently even more afraid, given that they are leading the protests: http://dcist.com/2016/02/housing.php Can they not see that this is a must for all wards, to break down infamous DC General? Can you not show a bit of compassion, especially when most of those families and kids are NOT white? |
I support closing DC general and creating small shelters but why all over the city and so far away from where they currently are living and enrolled in school and working? |
i would be more supportive of their stay was longer so they could actually integrate into the community rather just be there for a pit stop. |
Because all the data points towards this model. There was a great study done in MoCo where families were randomly assigned to housing in two different areas: yuppieville and crappyville. Guess what? The kids who lived in subsidized housing in yuppieville excelled, while the kids left behind in crappyville did not. If you are attempting to break the cycle of poverty, then you need to put these families in good communities where good behavior is modeled and the kids have an opportunity to succeed. |
I agree, but HUD doesn't. They only want to fund permanent housing, not transitional housing. Emergency shelters must quickly get people housed--through rapid rehousing. Hopefully this shelter will try to stably house these families in that community. |
Seriously do you think being there for 2 to 3 months will really make any huge impact? They won't be able to afford to stay in this new wonderful neighborhood. But have to leave after a few months and go to a more affordable less desirable neighborhood again? |
| the wisconsin ave one will be blocked, for sure...it's right ehind the vice president's home |
Copying behavior can go both ways. As much as model behavior can be copied, so can problem behavior be modeled by children already living there. There are studies on this too, but you are trying to ignore any negative statistics and truthful facts to get your program through. |
Not if they develop permanent housing in the area. Not if they secure partnerships with landlords. Not if they pilot a study to see how families housed in that neighborhood do after 25 years (like MoCo). |