My kid goes to Maury, and we don't live there, because like you, we can't afford to live there. We lotteried in and commute in on the bus. Can I afford to move to the suburbs? No, unless I move way out. So do I appreciate the lottery? Yes, because otherwise, I'd be stuck at my IB. |
What's fascinating is spending $1M+ on a home than worrying and complaining about the quality of schools. There is no way I'd ever do that unless I was a staunch believer in private schools. Seems like personal choices won over long-term planning. |
You sound unhinged. I'm not the poster you're responding to. I used to work at BASIS. We had multiple heads in a single chaotic school year. Try again with a different PP. |
What's fascinating, and sobering, to this CH resident since the 1990s is that all the worrying and complaining about the quality of schools never seems to coalesce into a viable political movement to improve DCPS middle and high schools EotP. It just never happens. Seems like political inertia wins over a push for good long-term planning on DCPS' part. I don't follow city politics all that closely Maybe I'd get it if I did. If you do, care to explain why progress on neighborhood schools after elementary remains glacial EotP in a heavily gentrified area? |
You would also be stuck at your IB if you hadn’t struck gold with the lottery. In fact unless you lotteried in 4th or 5th, it is unlikely you would have gotten a spot this year even with a great lottery number. For all but the wealthiest families, it’s just a game of chance. |
“For the same rent as anywhere” sure is an interesting metric. |
I mean, for the same rent as anywhere you can be IB for a good school in DC. The rents get cheaper in MoCo but you can rent something like this zoned for Maury: https://yarmouthm.com/listing/1123-park-st-ne/ That’s likely within the budget of most dual income MC families. |
The answer of course is....high performing public schools with good facilities in neighboring jurisdictions. This pressure valve serves as a bulwark against political pressure building to the point that city politicians, and the ed leaders who are beholden to them, have to take the complaints of umc parents East of Rock Creek seriously. Movers and shakers can stop at appeasing us with the better DCPS and charter middle school programs. They don't see a need to do more because there isn't one. You can live on CH for years as a parent with kids in public elementary schools without getting your head around this. |
|
I wish I could answer that question. IMO, it just seems like "this is what we have always done" vs actually demanding and fighting for change. Of course, there are the historical and present racial dynamics that play a big role also. I'm pretty sure it takes someone with deep historical knowledge of DC and DCPS to explain how things haven't progressed like they should. Most of the native elected leaders seem to have spent One of my neighbors simply stated "People have a lot of money here so private is no biggie to them." My response was "If you need FA, you can't afford private school for K-12." Of course, she said that I was wrong and mean I do think people believe that thou. Something has to give but the question is when.
|
There are two possible way Hill MS and HS could change: 1. Everyone could just send their kids and assume that a rising tide lifts all boats, same as elementary schools. Seems to be happening at EH. 2. DCPS could affirmatively court IB parents, as did Hardy. Seems to be a nonstarter right now. |
|
| We used to live in a Southern city where suburban schools weren’t much better than urban schools, so most middle class families went private. Here, if you want a good public school offering a well-rounded education after elementary you move a short way into VA and MD. Easy enough fix, your problem is solved. That’s the main reason no DC public middle school is very good all around. |
My theory about the lack of a viable political movement is because I think many of the posters have preschoolers or early elementary aged kids. They see rowdy teens and panic because their kids are young. As their kids grow in DCPS, they don’t have as much worry because those rowdy teens are now not so rowdy and include their kids and their kids’ friends. I like DCPS! Is it perfect? Nope! But guess what neither was their private school that I paid for them to attend. I would argue the vast majority of kids in MS and HS are pretty nice and bright. I think wealthy DC folks fear that poor is a communicable disease. It’s not. |
I think it is partly because there are too many choices in DC. It is hard for parents to act like one unified block. If your kid lucks into a highly sought after charter, you will take it and then not have the energy to fight the system. Some folks have the money to go private. Some folks just move to MD or VA which is tempting as they have better college options as well. And DC Govt doesn’t care as DC is ultra liberal and democrats never get voted out. |