DOWNTOWN RALLY Sex Workers Criticize Law Enforcement - Washington Post

Anonymous
By Theola Labbé-DeBose
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, December 18, 2008; Page B03

Dozens of sex workers marched through the streets of downtown Washington yesterday, demanding better treatment from law enforcement officials of prostitutes who become crime victims.

Clutching red umbrellas and carrying signs that read, "Sex Work Is Real Work" and "Stop Shaming Us to Death," the men and women came from San Francisco, New York and other cities across the country to publicize a rarely discussed issue that they say is not taken seriously.

The rally and march was organized by the Sex Workers Outreach Project, a San Francisco-based nonprofit, and coincided with today's fifth anniversary of the sentencing of Gary Leon Ridgway, a Seattle man known as the "Green River Killer" who was convicted of murdering 48 prostitutes in 21 years. The lowly status of prostitutes in society, rally participants said yesterday, explains why the crimes went unsolved for so long.

"I'm just so tired of hearing, 'If I choose to do X, then I put myself on the line,' " said Charmus, 34, a transgender woman who gave only her first name. She lives in Maryland and said she has worked as a prostitute. "Transgender women, prostitutes, you have a right to fight for due process," she said to the crowd assembled at a downtown park.

As professional workers filed out of buildings in suits and ties on their way to business lunches, the rally crowd marched from Franklin Square at 14th and I streets NW to the Justice Department in the 900 block of Pennsylvania Avenue NW. Along the way, the marchers encountered some bemused looks at signs reading, "Be Nice to Sex Workers."

A 33-year-old man from New York City who gave his name as Wally said he works as an escort in Manhattan. He has been fortunate not to be a crime victim, he said, but he made the trip to show solidarity.


"I do this to survive," he said

Once the protesters reached the Justice Department, they stood on the sidewalk and told their stories under the watchful eyes of federal police officers. Leila, a 24-year-old woman from San Francisco, shared an experience that she said showed the importance of sex workers banding together.

Leila said a client wanted to pay her at the end of their date and even provided his passport as collateral. She was skeptical, but agreed. Then the client said he needed to take money out of the bank, and she went with him. But at the teller, the client asked for his passport back for identification. When Leila handed it back, the man ran.

Leila told the protesters that she chased the man and even caught up with him. He punched her in the face. But when she complained to police, she said, they threatened to arrest her for working as a prostitute.

Since the date was arranged online, Leila said, she went to her computer and noticed warnings about the client posted by other women. The women shared information about him, and eventually they found his workplace and told his boss that the man had been meeting prostitutes during the workday and assaulting them. He was fired, Leila said.

"Alone, we're just prostitutes on the corner and no one respects us," she said. "Together we are a political movement, and we can change things."
Anonymous
This is great! I am proud of them for speaking out.
Anonymous
Next week's protest will feature Johnny crack-head.
Anonymous
They are breaking the law by working as prostitutes!!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Next week's protest will feature Johnny crack-head.


Hysterical...and all too true!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:They are breaking the law by working as prostitutes!!


Frankly, these laws need to sbe taken off the books.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:They are breaking the law by working as prostitutes!!


Frankly, these laws need to sbe taken off the books.


Who ARE you people? Why in the world should prostitution be legalized? What one single positive thing comes from prostitution? Unbelievable.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:They are breaking the law by working as prostitutes!!


Frankly, these laws need to sbe taken off the books.


Who ARE you people? Why in the world should prostitution be legalized? What one single positive thing comes from prostitution? Unbelievable.


Agree, completely. Even Amsterdam is trying desperately to shut down its legalized prostitution. Guess what? Prostitution does nothing good, but attracts such a bad element and so much crime (most of it drug related) and abuse, that Amsterdam finally realized it's ruining the city.

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:They are breaking the law by working as prostitutes!!


Frankly, these laws need to sbe taken off the books.


Who ARE you people? Why in the world should prostitution be legalized? What one single positive thing comes from prostitution? Unbelievable.


Agree, completely. Even Amsterdam is trying desperately to shut down its legalized prostitution. Guess what? Prostitution does nothing good, but attracts such a bad element and so much crime (most of it drug related) and abuse, that Amsterdam finally realized it's ruining the city.



Amsterdam is cleaning up the red light district, but it is not outlawing prostitution. It's more like the way NYC cleaned up Times Square by tossing out some seedy businesses and revitalizing a blighted area.

But here is the problem with taking criminal action against prostitutes: the number of women who are coerced into prostitution is very large, especially the immigrants. The only way women break out of these sex rings or get free of their pimps is to go to the authorities. But if they fear the authorities, they have no one to turn to.
Anonymous
PP Precisely. I don't like or love prostitution and if I or we as a society could make it go away that would be great. History seems to say it is not going anywhere. In the mean time, however, I don't think that it is ok for a prostitute to get beaten or coerced and not be able to seek some legal redress. Prostitutes are people just like everyone else and the reason they are in that profession varies. I think it is very oppressive personally, but having it be illegal where mostly street prostitutes are arrested and the johns and pimps are strutting around b/c the cops and laws won't help prostitutes when they are brutalized or victims of crims is ridiculous.

I do not think prostitution should be legalized but I think it should be decriminalized. If you research the issue only about 10% of prostitution is street prostitution and the real deal is the call girls, bachelor parties, strip clubs, champagne rooms, etc. If prostitution was decriminalized then these individuals would have some redress when they are harmed by others and maybe if they had more rights and more visability then we as a society could hold the johns and clubs more accountable. I don't see how you could be so heartless as to say women, men or others can be victims of crime b/c they sell their body for sex but those who buy it (including all the politcians, many husbands, boyfriends, women, etc or whoever) have all the protections. That is the ways the laws currently end up playing out. The street walkers get arrested and everyone else has a party.

Funny...I don't see how seeking human rights for all equates with the argument that positive things come from prostitution. It is illegal right now and I can direct you to about a million internet ads, newspaper ads, websites, clubs, street corners, etc. where it is alive and well. Obviously, the laws are not succeeding in this area and the more intelligent analysis would be look at why.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:PP Precisely. I don't like or love prostitution and if I or we as a society could make it go away that would be great. History seems to say it is not going anywhere. In the mean time, however, I don't think that it is ok for a prostitute to get beaten or coerced and not be able to seek some legal redress. Prostitutes are people just like everyone else and the reason they are in that profession varies. I think it is very oppressive personally, but having it be illegal where mostly street prostitutes are arrested and the johns and pimps are strutting around b/c the cops and laws won't help prostitutes when they are brutalized or victims of crims is ridiculous.

I do not think prostitution should be legalized but I think it should be decriminalized. If you research the issue only about 10% of prostitution is street prostitution and the real deal is the call girls, bachelor parties, strip clubs, champagne rooms, etc. If prostitution was decriminalized then these individuals would have some redress when they are harmed by others and maybe if they had more rights and more visability then we as a society could hold the johns and clubs more accountable. I don't see how you could be so heartless as to say women, men or others can be victims of crime b/c they sell their body for sex but those who buy it (including all the politcians, many husbands, boyfriends, women, etc or whoever) have all the protections. That is the ways the laws currently end up playing out. The street walkers get arrested and everyone else has a party.

Funny...I don't see how seeking human rights for all equates with the argument that positive things come from prostitution. It is illegal right now and I can direct you to about a million internet ads, newspaper ads, websites, clubs, street corners, etc. where it is alive and well. Obviously, the laws are not succeeding in this area and the more intelligent analysis would be look at why.


Well, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I and a majority of the population vehemently disagrees with you.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:PP Precisely. I don't like or love prostitution and if I or we as a society could make it go away that would be great. History seems to say it is not going anywhere. In the mean time, however, I don't think that it is ok for a prostitute to get beaten or coerced and not be able to seek some legal redress. Prostitutes are people just like everyone else and the reason they are in that profession varies. I think it is very oppressive personally, but having it be illegal where mostly street prostitutes are arrested and the johns and pimps are strutting around b/c the cops and laws won't help prostitutes when they are brutalized or victims of crims is ridiculous.

I do not think prostitution should be legalized but I think it should be decriminalized. If you research the issue only about 10% of prostitution is street prostitution and the real deal is the call girls, bachelor parties, strip clubs, champagne rooms, etc. If prostitution was decriminalized then these individuals would have some redress when they are harmed by others and maybe if they had more rights and more visability then we as a society could hold the johns and clubs more accountable. I don't see how you could be so heartless as to say women, men or others can be victims of crime b/c they sell their body for sex but those who buy it (including all the politcians, many husbands, boyfriends, women, etc or whoever) have all the protections. That is the ways the laws currently end up playing out. The street walkers get arrested and everyone else has a party.

Funny...I don't see how seeking human rights for all equates with the argument that positive things come from prostitution. It is illegal right now and I can direct you to about a million internet ads, newspaper ads, websites, clubs, street corners, etc. where it is alive and well. Obviously, the laws are not succeeding in this area and the more intelligent analysis would be look at why.


Well, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I and a majority of the population vehemently disagrees with you.


I think that if you met a child forced into prostitution and heard her story, you might change your opinion. That's what happened for me. I was on a jury in a child prostitution case. I am now for prosecuting the pimps and the johns, but for decriminalizing the act of prostitution. So if you feel strongly about this issue, advocate for prosecution the johns. They are probably part of your "majority of the population".


Anonymous
Prostitution is exploitation. Men (and women) use prostitutes to do things that they themselves would never do. Do you think Spitzer would want his daughters doing that? No way, but he sure could make use of the prostitutes.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:PP Precisely. I don't like or love prostitution and if I or we as a society could make it go away that would be great. History seems to say it is not going anywhere. In the mean time, however, I don't think that it is ok for a prostitute to get beaten or coerced and not be able to seek some legal redress. Prostitutes are people just like everyone else and the reason they are in that profession varies. I think it is very oppressive personally, but having it be illegal where mostly street prostitutes are arrested and the johns and pimps are strutting around b/c the cops and laws won't help prostitutes when they are brutalized or victims of crims is ridiculous.

I do not think prostitution should be legalized but I think it should be decriminalized. If you research the issue only about 10% of prostitution is street prostitution and the real deal is the call girls, bachelor parties, strip clubs, champagne rooms, etc. If prostitution was decriminalized then these individuals would have some redress when they are harmed by others and maybe if they had more rights and more visability then we as a society could hold the johns and clubs more accountable. I don't see how you could be so heartless as to say women, men or others can be victims of crime b/c they sell their body for sex but those who buy it (including all the politcians, many husbands, boyfriends, women, etc or whoever) have all the protections. That is the ways the laws currently end up playing out. The street walkers get arrested and everyone else has a party.

Funny...I don't see how seeking human rights for all equates with the argument that positive things come from prostitution. It is illegal right now and I can direct you to about a million internet ads, newspaper ads, websites, clubs, street corners, etc. where it is alive and well. Obviously, the laws are not succeeding in this area and the more intelligent analysis would be look at why.


Well, you are certainly entitled to your opinion, but I and a majority of the population vehemently disagrees with you.


I think that if you met a child forced into prostitution and heard her story, you might change your opinion. That's what happened for me. I was on a jury in a child prostitution case. I am now for prosecuting the pimps and the johns, but for decriminalizing the act of prostitution. So if you feel strongly about this issue, advocate for prosecution the johns. They are probably part of your "majority of the population".

But that child is not a "sex worker" . She is a victim of criminal behavior. Decriminalizing the behavior would not protect that child.


Anonymous
PP here and obviously I am not including children in any analysis regarding this issue. A child is not a sex worker but a child forced into prostitution. It is horrible. That child is a victim of criminal behavior and deserves protection as a child. Anytime a child is victimized the laws should protect them. A child being forced into prostitution or anyone being forced into prostitution is a separate crime-trafficking, etc. A young girl of 12 who is picked up off the streets for prostitution by a cop and is then sent off to juvenile hall for breaking the law is not being assisted in anyway. Her pimp or whoever should be prosecuted and she or he should receive all sorts of assistance.

In these discussions people are mixing apples and oranges. These are really complicated issues that will not get resolved on this forum.
Forum Index » Political Discussion
Go to: