Just had to throw away $33.00 - yucks!

Anonymous
Bought a red snapper (whole) at WF on Tuesday and asked the guy if it would be good by today. He said yes - well, once I took it out of the wrapper it was clearly spoiled or beginning to. Glazed eyes and when I poked the flesh it didn't bounced back.

Upset with myself...argh!!! I never cook fish, I don't know how to. But I ate a lot of it during our vacation and decided to try. It didn't work out very well I guess....
Anonymous
Then return it! They'll take it back--tell them the fishmonger lied to you.
Anonymous
This should be posted in the food forum.
Anonymous
I would never even consider cooking fresh fish three days after buying it.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I would never even consider cooking fresh fish three days after buying it.


Plus 1. Seafood guy obviously did not have a clue.
Anonymous
Did any corn come with it?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:This should be posted in the food forum.


Maybe the fish was pretty and well dressed.



Anonymous
Take it back, Whole Foods is good about taking things even without a receipt.
Anonymous
OMG. Who would buy fresh fish to serve 3 days later?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:OMG. Who would buy fresh fish to serve 3 days later?


Isn't there a Ben Franklin saying about how "houseguests, like fish, start to smell after 3 days"? Definitely a 3 day rule on fish and that's assuming it was fresh to start with.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OMG. Who would buy fresh fish to serve 3 days later?


Isn't there a Ben Franklin saying about how "houseguests, like fish, start to smell after 3 days"? Definitely a 3 day rule on fish and that's assuming it was fresh to start with.


Um, yeah, don't buy fish till the day you are ready to cook it.
Anonymous
OP here. First, I post in the wrong forum by mistake. Sorry for that.

Second, as I said I don't have any experience cooking fish and relied in his info. I already threw it away and can't return. But lesson learned. Tomorrow I will buy another one to cook in the evening.
Anonymous
Fish and houseguests stink after 3 days.
Anonymous
Gross. Three day old fish!
Anonymous
Wow, so many "mean girls" on here. The OP said she doesn't know anything about cooking fish! Give her a break. I'm surprised Whole Foods gave such wrong information.
post reply Forum Index » Food, Cooking, and Restaurants
Message Quick Reply
Go to: