My spouse is a teacher in a MS and says it’s nowhere near that high, but truancy and disrespect is a bigger issue than fighting and drug use. |
This is a ridiculous exaggeration. I would suspect it is less than 5%. Right after Covid, there was data about discipline and most of the incidents were done by the same small group of kids. We don’t need metal detectors. We need discipline and consequences again. |
My teens are at Region 4 large schools and I teach in Region 5 at the secondary level. I never said "it's fine". It's anything but fine. My younger two are going to private school next year because we are tired of administrators who do nothing and students who are out of control. However, it is not 20-30% of students who are causing problems. That's a huge exaggeration. |
| You can’t have high expectations without consequences. It’s human nature and we are fully aware of that in almost every setting except public schools. Consequences help kids stay on the right path and push kids to course correct once they’ve made a mistake. The biggest issue in FCPS currently is the lack of meaningful consequences when kids mess up. The problem is FCPS parents want consequences until it’s their child in the crosshairs. Then they threaten lawsuits and fight to protect their child at the expense of the rest of the students. WE DID THIS TO OURSELVES!! |
The county is just poorer. FARMS rates have doubled in the last 15 years. It won’t be long before the 1/2 the county is FARMS. Unfortunately, poverty brings these challenges to schools. |
A low percentage of discipline issues are being reported and investigated and written up. My child knows tons of kids who vape and do weed carts everyday at school and don’t get caught. They hide it in the bathrooms. Staff and parents here thinking “it’s not 20%” are not aware of the kids doing drugs and fighting at school but just don’t get caught because schools are understaffed for security and teachers are over-extended. It’s not 5-10%. A higher number of kids than you realize are in trouble, it might be your kid abd you don’t even know since parents aren’t monitoring their kids electronic usage or supervising. |
|
15% of Fairfax county teens reported vaping in the last month
https://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/data/sites/data/files/assets/documents/youth%20survey/tobacco%20-%20fcys%2019.pdf |
That is a troubling statistic. However, did you know that in the fifties some high schools had "smoking areas?" I'm confident the percentage of teens smoking then was higher than 15 %. I'm not downplaying that stat. Again, it is very troubling. |
Yes, and who is going to pay for it? |
| The National recommendation for School Resource Officers is 1 SRO per 1000 students. West Springfield HS has 2 SRO. Lake Braddock secondary school has 2 SROs for about 4000 students. Robinson Secondary has 2SRO for about 4000 students. West Potomac has 1 SRO (they should have 3). That’s unsafe. They need more SRO and security assistants to monitor the halls, common areas, bathrooms, and cafeterias to keep the order Nd enforce rules. Let the teachers focus on teaching. Get help with unsafe environments. |
There are people on here who work in the schools who are saying it's not 20-30% of their students who are fighting/causing trouble. |
It’s more like 5%-10%. The vast majority of kids are fine. A select few keep the administrators very busy. -Teacher at a ‘nice’ school. |
I taught primary grades. One disruptive child can have a huge impact on a class. I'm not talking about the "chatty" ones, but the ones who take up a very high percentage of the teacher's time. I taught a number of classes with a handful of kids who regularly misbehaved, but were not out of control. But, when you have one who is out of control, it can be quite destructive. |
Sure, but what does that have to do with the claim that 20-30% of students are doing drugs and fighting? |
I don't remember the last time our huge, 9 rated fcps high school had a fight. Your 20-30% number is not accurate. |