That's complete nonsense. Limiting TJ to a few wealthy feeders doesn't serve Fairfax county tax payers. |
Academically advanced feeders is what FCPS nurtures by maintaining higher standards and challenging the students appropriately, and students there reciprocate by putting in more efforts, inside and outside school. That is why FCPS admits the top one third of every TJ class overwhelmingly from the top four schools. They are not looking towards athletically wealthy feeders because their strengths and interests are different. Every school's student body has their own priorities and tax pay money is allocated accordingly to support their efforts. And parents spend their enrichment money on either sports or academics or something else. |
DP There is no way to know if the very top students are being admitted because there is no single, objective metric that allows for comparison. They need to bring back standardized testing; then you can see students relative academic strengths and know if your statement is true. GPAs are subjective and are not fulfilling their screening purpose - witness the recent admission of students with 3.5+ GPAs who later fail their SOL exam(s) at TJ. Using standardized test results (ie SOLs, PSAT, or other) could have prevented those latter students from being set up to struggle at TJ. |
My understanding is the county has access to these metrics and uses them to identify the top students. |
You’re full of crap. By your own logic limiting access to TJ to 4% of FCPS high school students ought to be equally distressing to taxpayers. Unless, of course, you’re just angling to improve your own kid’s odds of being in that 4% at the expense of more qualified applicants. |
Your understanding is incorrect. None of those metrics are used by or even seen by the members of the TJ admissions panel. They only see verification that the student is eligible to apply to TJ, the GPA, the essays, FARMS status, ESOL status, and IEP status. |
You’ve already been rebutted. Trotting out the same stale references to “wealthy feeders” dozens of times per day just reveals the shallowness of your intellect. |
One thing everyone is overlooking here: The new process greatly increased the number of Prince William County kids getting accepted into TJ. The acceptance rate for PWC kids (~31%) is almost twice as high as FCPS kids (~16%), despite the kids being much worse academically.
PWC had *1* of the 81 TJ NMSF, out of like 80 accepted kids. |
What metrics? Not the SOL. One of the kids in our school that everyone thought would get in had 590+ in all their SOLs and they didn't get in. They got an award for best geometry student from the teachers at graduation. |
Each jurisdiction selects kids separately. So PWC kids are only competing with PWC kids. |
I am hopeful that the new principal can keep the low stress environment without abandoning rigor. |
TJ should only be accessible to wealthy feeders because we pay more taxes! |
The previous principal did an excellent job maintaining high standards while reducing the test prep cheaters, which helped with the toxicity. |
In the old system, there were no guaranteed set-asides for each jurisdiction. Very few PWC kids were academically strong enough to be selected in the old process. |
Test prep is not cheating. Studying is not cheating. Nobody believes that it is. Not even you. Only cheating is cheating. You should stop denigrating the hard work and effort of some kids just because you want opportunity for other kids. I think Bonitatibus was focused on mental health especially in light of the two suicides during her tenure. I think these may be the first suicides at TJ since its inception and it must have weighed heavy on her as it would on any principal. |