DA players not eligible to play for HS teams?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The only local tournament with DA teams last weekend was the VDA Girls Showcase. https://www.gotsport.com/m/events/results.aspx?EventID=70391&Gend

From the results it looks like the teams only played 2 games, not 3, but anyway,...

Not surpising that ECNL teams would beat GDA teams. Old news.

The DA does not allow DA teams to play multiple games on the same day. That is why the DA teams only played 2 games.

Right, but PP says his team played 3 DA teams. There were only the two Spirit teams at that showcase on the DA side from what it looks like. So in a given age group, there weren't even 3 to play. (And as a side note, the free substitution rules change the game for DA players accustomed to limited sub....)

More relevant to the discussion in THIS thread -- key point is the one about the DA not allowing DA teams to play multiple games in one day. DA rules on this AND high school are a lot about managing the training and game volume for the player to keep it appropriate for development and not overload adolescent bodies.... That's not a bad thing.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My kid played in a tournament last weekend and 3 of the teams they played were academy teams, There was not a single stand out player and there wasn't a victory for either of the 3 DA teams.

Only difference I saw was they had winter jackets instead of hoodies.

What tournament was last weekend? Oh, the jacket comment is hysterical!

The only local tournament with DA teams last weekend was the VDA Girls Showcase. https://www.gotsport.com/m/events/results.aspx?EventID=70391&Gend

From the results it looks like the teams only played 2 games, not 3, but anyway,...

Not surpising that ECNL teams would beat GDA teams. Old news.

There is another thread that has gone over this showcase and its results ad naseum. Unless your kid plays on a non-DA or ECNL team and you're arguing that your team is better, then we don't need to rehash the "Is the DA better than ECNL or not" conversation with points drawn against and for from a meaningless winter showcase. I'm pretty sure the ECNL teams also had fancy jackets though, so maybe you ARE arguing that? If so, tell us what club you are from.

Yeah, sorry, I was just one of those trying to call BS on PP - both on the number of games and the results. I should have said it's not surprising that some ECNL teams would beat some GDA teams, and vice versa. Old news in the sense that, as you say, the GDA v ECNL debate has been hashed out ad nauseam.

I'm not sure what point the PP was trying to make other than to take a pot shot at the DA.

BDA parent btw.

[Anonymous]

the fact that people actually went though the results of each age group really shows you all have some serious issues and living through your kids.

Wow I wonder what you talk about at dinner?

Let me guess.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:the fact that people actually went though the results of each age group really shows you all have some serious issues and living through your kids.

Wow I wonder what you talk about at dinner?

Let me guess.

I’d think the VDA parent was already there and knew it was BS. Should they have let the BS stand? Kudos to them for correcting yet another piece of garbage info in this forum.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:the fact that people actually went though the results of each age group really shows you all have some serious issues and living through your kids.

I love someone who is not only reading, but also posting to, a soccer-only blog, calling out other posters for being crazy and not having a life. I appreciate PP's point, but everyone who reads and posts is on the spectrum of being crazy and soccer-obsessed. I get that some are crazier than others, but let's all be honest with ourselves and not throw stones from our glass houses.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:the fact that people actually went though the results of each age group really shows you all have some serious issues and living through your kids.

Wow I wonder what you talk about at dinner?

Let me guess.

No, anyone who knows the DA restrictions to one game a day and was actually at the showcase knew the PP was total BS. It only took 3 minutes to call it and prove it.

[Anonymous]

The Arlington girls DA has players who play on their private school team(s) and thus sit out the fall DA. It is not true that none of the 3 VA DAs disallows waivers. It is happening.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The Arlington girls DA has players who play on their private school team(s) and thus sit out the fall DA. It is not true that none of the 3 VA DAs disallows waivers. It is happening.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The Arlington girls DA has players who play on their private school team(s) and thus sit out the fall DA. It is not true that none of the 3 VA DAs disallows waivers. It is happening.

So what? Private school waivers can be granted. The player is still not allowed to play or train with the DA team during the HS season.

[Anonymous]

Someone earlier in this thread posted that no waivers were granted to any of the 3 girls DA teams in VA. I think the PP was just responding to that statement when she said it was not true, as evidenced by the Arlington girls.

[Anonymous]

DA will announce soon that they will allow HS to intice more clubs to rejoin DA. That's the word from someone in the know. Thats all I know.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DA will announce soon that they will allow HS to intice more clubs to rejoin DA. That's the word from someone in the know. Thats all I know.

Have heard the same, and will include boys DA.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DA will announce soon that they will allow HS to intice more clubs to rejoin DA. That's the word from someone in the know. Thats all I know.

Have heard the same, and will include boys DA.

That's interesting. On the girls side, I wonder whether this will have the effect that DA is hoping for. If both DA and ECNL allow high school soccer, then why would a girls club in ECNL switch to DA? What is the advantage gained by doing so?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DA will announce soon that they will allow HS to intice more clubs to rejoin DA. That's the word from someone in the know. Thats all I know.

Good lord. How can anyone take the DA seriously. It appears their motives are more political than anything else.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DA will announce soon that they will allow HS to intice more clubs to rejoin DA. That's the word from someone in the know. Thats all I know.

Good lord. How can anyone take the DA seriously. It appears their motives are more political than anything else.

So more CLUBS will join DA? WTF? Is every Club going to have a DA team soon? Dilution