I didn't even think of that, but great point! |
Only if you're trying to market the home to the broadest swath of people possible. |
Interior columns have their place. We have a house built in the 30's that has some square columns at an archway between the foyer and the dining room that are original to the house. They are consistent with the architecture of the house and nicely delineate the space while still giving the area an open feel. I have seen some modern McMansions that have random columns stuck around that look a little odd. |
I love open floor plans. So much more friends and family friendly. I'm not a formal person. My 80 year old inlaws prefer the closed off kitchen/dining room. They are very formal. When we have get togethers, people hang out in the kitchen. It doesn't matter if I put the food out in the dining room. They all seem to congregate in the kitchen area. So, we just blew out the walls to the kitchen/family room, and now we can have people hang out in the kitchen area and not feel cramped. Kids hang out in the finished basement. Adults hang out in the kitchen/family room. It's great. I am getting sick of the gray/white kitchen and subway tiles. I like color. |
Open floor plan. |
My dislike of open floor plans has more to do with privacy and noise reduction. Of course if you want to go the noise reduction route, it helps to have insulation in interior walls and 2 layers of drywall. Of course most older homes don't have that combo. |
Everything grey and white. I like grey and white, in reasonable doses, but it's just so sterile and cold when it's EVERYWHERE. |
Tile that looks like wood. Gag.
|
I'm the closed floor plan person above. It's all personal preference, but when it comes to kitchens and you do ethnic cooking, a closed floorplan can be more desirable for certain cuisines. Infact some builders market towards newer asian arrivals for having a second small kitchen for stirfrying and a larger main kitchen for entertaining. Even if you have a 1200CFM fan above your stove to ameliorate the smells, the oil can still easily get on your fancy backsplash. I think you listed the many positives though. |
The only place that works is in a basement for obvious reasons. On a main floor, kitchen, or bath it looks strange. |
+ 1 |
Please post more actual pictures of the trends you hate. |
Can someone please post examples of this ever-hated "new farm house" that's so awful? Thanks. |
Just use walls. This would also eliminate a pet peeve of mine, trying to make every house an ultra-open floor plan. Then you won't have columns you feel like you need to hide by covering in faux-marble frou frou. |
I cook ethnic foods, as do many of my friends. So, if someone doesn't like the ethnic food smell, then we probably wouldn't get along with them that well anyways to have them over often. IMO, the kitchen area is the heart of the home. I like it to be roomy, bright and airy. |