If people are so worried about this, they should put their little genius into bad schools. |
What a valuable comment here. |
I don't think discussion was about little geniuses who make into Magnets. A poster asked a simple question about kids who just fall short of magnet bench mark or simply not interested to join magnet. Does their chance decreases due to magnet kids coming from outside or it has no impact. I do think it's a very genuine point and you don't have to be sarcastic about it. |
They’re never going to Ivy League schools anyway then now are they? I don’t see what the big deal is. |
Point is a simple one. They don't go to Ivy league. Understood and clear. They can go to a level below Ivy league. Assume that there are 50-70 seats a level below Ivy league which will be filled by RM graduates. Do you think that having magnet decreases chance of non-IB students to grab those 50-70 seats? Do you think due to 100 magnet students coming from outside make it difficult for non-IB students to get seats a tier below Ivy? |
Most people living RM will probably just go to University of Maryland anyway. Also, many of the homes are actually walkable to Montgomery college. If a student is ambitious enough they could take college classes while in High School. I was never a genius or the top of my class but had ambition and did just that and had to drive to the college. It’s probably even easier for kids today - especially with the main Montgomery College campus being right there. |
UMD has become tough to get in as well. I don't know how many from RM( non-IB) go to UMD. I do know that majority of Blair and RM magnet kids attend UMD. That may decrese chance of attending UMD for kids who are not in magnets in Blair/RM. We are not in these two schools, but veyr interesting point raised here. |
I think the presence of the magnet makes it more difficult for every student at the school to get into any college that limits its offers of admission to just 2 or 3 per school. The Ivies certainly do that. I don't know about the next tier down private schools - don't follow admissions to them all. The presence of the magnet doesn't hurt students applying to top public universities - UMD, UVA, and other top universities take many students from RM. But from a big picture standpoint, the students in the home school population that don't choose the IB diploma program are probably not as strong academically as those that do, and have a harder time competing just from an academic standpoint. |
| 12:34 may be the dumbest comment on this thread. Totally not true that most RM kids go to UMD or can walk to MC. Sheesh. That comment should be deleted. Go back under your bridge. |
Your suggestion for someone to take classes at Montgomery College if they are not challenged at RM probably won't work for most... you may not be aware, but many classes at MC are either remedial or less challenging than equivalent AP/IB classes at RM, so I don't think taking any one of those classes would impress colleges. |
|
Applied and Accepted numbers:
https://bethesdamagazine.com/bethesda-magazine/september-october-2018/where-bethesda-area-high-school-grads-applied-to-college/2/ UMDCP: applied 291 Accepted: 141 I don't know that all 141 are in IB because look at the accepted at Ivies from RM as well as other top schools. |
I know for a fact not all 141 were from RMIB. Because I know 2 kids from RM '18 who weren't IB but were accepted to Maryland. (1 declined, 1 enrolled.) |
That makes only “139.” LOL |
Isn't there only 125 Magnet students per class? |
Old days, yes. Apparently now the program is bigger to include non magnet kids. |