What is your AAP rising 3rd grader reading this summer?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
+1. My kid is reading Captain Underpants and Dog Man. I just don't believe a rising 3rd grader is enjoying The Odyssey(even in AAP)...at least come up with believeable lies people! |
Anonymous
Good for your kid for liking Captain Underpants. Is your kid or experience the measuring stick for the rest of the world? My kid is reading Big Nate, Star Wars, Jurassic World books, The American Pageant, and AP Biology (specifically DNA and Genetics). Why would someone need to lie on an anonymous forum? You are the typical person who wants advantages by trying to make people look like liars. |
Anonymous
Classic starts books are classics rewritten to about a 4th grade reading level. |
Anonymous
What advantages are you talking about? No, an 8 year old is not reading Odyssey for funnies. LOL Why would someone lie on an anonymous forum? Good question. You should ask that person. Sometimes it's trolling. Sometimes they get a kick out of "impressing" other parents. |
Anonymous
What is your problem? I'm the PP who posted that my kid read the Classic Starts version of the Odyssey. It's a kid version of the book and not at all the same one people read in high school. My kid is really into Percy Jackson and wanted to read some Greek mythology. Considering how many kid versions of the Odyssey are floating around, a lot of kids must be interested in reading it. I don't know why you're so hung up on kids reading kid versions of the Odyssey. 
|
Anonymous
Putting down people by not acknowledging or denying what they are doing, essentially makes you look like you're doing what can be done. This in your eyes puts you at a position average or above, when in fact you aren't. Anyway, this much philosophy is out of scope for this topic. |
Anonymous
|
Amelia Bedelia. He is in AAP, but is not a gifted reader -- at least as measured by the books he reads.
I can't stand Captain Underpants. |
Anonymous
| There’s a good thread in the ES school forum about books right now |
Anonymous
Are those kids AAP? |
Anonymous
No, but it’s your loss if you don’t want the suggestions for that reason. I went to an Ivy League college and I still like the picture book genre as an adult. I don’t censor what my kids read, in either direction. That’s how I think you foster a love of reading. |
Anonymous
Ivy League colleges don't impress me. I've seen too many dunces come from those in the workplace. I let my kid read what they want for exactly the reason you list here. I don't suggest books we just browse stores and libraries and whatever catches their eye is what they read. |
Anonymous
| mostly whatever type is on the screen while he plays NB2K and Fortnite. :/ |
Anonymous
|
Rising second grader, an advanced reader, is reading a lot of schlock from my youth (Microprose Adventures), schlock from his cousin's youth (N.E.R.D.S, Star Wars novelizations), militariana, and things that, with the subtlety of a serpent, I leave in the bathroom for him to find (D'Aulaires' Book of Greek Myths, a child-friendly version of Pilgrim's Progress).
Have heard of Captain Underpants before; this is a good reminder to check it out from the library. |
Anonymous
LOL, love it! |
Anonymous
| Beowulf |