You are still debating. |
|
OP, sorry about the PPs giving you a hard time. It is extremely unhelpful.
Have you tried the web site My Asperger's Child? I think they have some advice and book suggestions for discussing your child's diagnosis with your child. Also, T. Attwood's book, The Complete Guide to Asperger's Syndrome, has a Resources section that includes fiction and non- fiction books about explaining the diagnosis to your child. Sorry i don't have my copy handy. |
|
Nice try. It's a discussion forum.
And more than one person has issues they want to discuss. And really- toughen up. It's the Internet. If you don't like what someone is saying- ignore it!! |
| Then do a s/I thread. You are off the topic |
| Op here: thank you to the 2-3 people who tried to be helpful with books or websites that may have book ideas. To the rest...good grief. Perhaps my son loves math and computers and WE chose a lead in that worked for US? Obviously that was but a snippet of what was said and, again, was only trying to respond to someone answering my BOOK posting. I realize school is starting and we're all probably tense but so many of you are nasty and combative in your posts - more than usual. Thx again to those who stayed in topic and tried to help. Anyone else who has book ideas, thank you in advance. |
| Op here: thank you very much!! |
|
OP didn't just make that up. It's widely accepted in the ASD community and by experts that Einstein was on the spectrum.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retrospective_diagnoses_of_autism OP, sorry you were so unfairly targeted here. Bunch of ingoramuses. Here's a list of books, hope you'll find a couple that are helpful. At least one of them also lists Einstein as having had ASD. You're a great parent, good luck! http://www.parenting.com/gallery/autism-books?page=2 |
From your link: Speculation of this sort is, by necessity, based on reported behavior and anecdotal evidence rather than any clinical observation of the individual. Psychologist and author Oliver Sacks wrote that many of these claims seem "very thin at best",[12] and Fred Volkmar, of the Yale Child Study Center, has remarked that "there is unfortunately a sort of cottage industry of finding that everyone has Asperger's".[13] Michael Fitzgerald's research, in particular, has been heavily criticised, and described by some as "fudged pseudoscience"[14] and "frankly absurd".[15] |
You missed the first part: "Isaac Newton (1643–1727), Nikola Tesla (1856-1943) and Albert Einstein (1879–1955) all died before Asperger syndrome became known, but Ioan James,[4] Michael Fitzgerald,[7] and Simon Baron-Cohen[36] believe their personalities are consistent with those of people with Asperger syndrome. Tony Attwood has also named Einstein as a likely case of mild autism.[23] So four experts agree on retrospective ASD diagnoses, and two disagree. Elliott disagrees because Einstein had a sense of humor. Hmmm... I know several people with ASD who are hilarious. Besides, the point is that OP used experts' opinions to present to her child, based on her son's interest in those people's biographies. She did not make up the diagnoses herself. The meanness she experienced here is not warranted. |
You simply can't go back in time and (mis)diagnose the dead. If you actually read the biographies of these people, you'd know they didn't have autism. It's simple wishful thinking on the part of some people today. |
How? What makes you more knowledgeable then scientists who study autism? Are you an expert in the field? Do you have ASD? |
I apparently know more than you. Einstein had no repetitive behaviors, and a robust social (and love) life. The facts point to learning differences in his early life, but not to autism. |
|
Or this article, whee Baron-Cohen admits he was just speculating:
https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn3676-einstein-and-newton-showed-signs-of-autism/ hey were certainly geniuses, but did Albert Einstein and Isaac Newton also have autism? According to autism expert Simon Baron-Cohen, they might both have shown many signs of Asperger syndrome, a form of the condition that does not cause learning difficulties. Although he admits that it is impossible to make a definite diagnosis for someone who is no longer living, Baron-Cohen says he hopes this kind of analysis can shed light on why some people with autism excel in life, while others struggle. and later But Baron-Cohen thinks the idea is still worth considering – there may be certain niches in society where people with AS can flourish for their strengths rather than their social skills, he says. “This condition can make people depressed or suicidal, so if we can find out how to make things easier for them, that’s worthwhile.” |
|