Come on my teacher friend - use your words, just try - try. |
Perhaps those teachers were horrible. |
No. You are incorrect. We do think some of our students and ESPECIALLY our parents are crazy. Crazy as in 100% certifiable. Most teachers could write a book about all the crazy they deal with every day. Actually, your posts provide pretty good insight into the mind of a crazy parent. Where do you think all the messed up kids come from? The apple doesn't fall far from the tree, unfortunately. |
Just for extra info, this family was the wealthiest family in the town (rural does not necessarily mean poor - there are some very well off farming and ranching families, they are just more spread out in rural areas). The private college they ended up sending her to was not cheap and due to a pretty small endowment they had a far less substantial commitment to financial aid to admitted students than any of the Ivies. She asked my opinion on colleges and where she should apply. She was a scholarship candidate anywhere and I told her as much. I had a similar profile to this student when I graduated high school and received full scholarships to several private universities including the one Ivy League school I applied to. I wasn't far removed from that experience at the time, so it was still the way things worked, maybe that is not so true anymore, I haven't taught in a rural area or a non-coastal state in several years now. I think there is a misconception that nearby or state schools *always* translate to less debt for grads. That can be true, it would almost certainly be true if you were talking UMD vs. say William and Mary for most local kids. It's not necessarily true if you are applying to a school with a strong commitment to aid and you are representing a group that is underrepresented in some way, such as a kid from a rural community in a state that sends very very few people to that school. The counselor for our school was shared between more than one school district (rotated days) due to size and since many of the kids were not college bound, her default was to push the nearby (relatively) religious college or for a top student like this girl she encouraged the closest satellite campus of the state university. There were no college reps visiting this school outside of those 2 schools either so there weren't really any resources for a kid to even learn about any other schools. As a postscript, she didn't apply to an Ivy, but she did apply to a couple of very competitive private schools. She received really great scholarship offers. At the religious college they didn't have much money to give - I think their largest scholarship was 10,000 for merit at the time. She wouldn't have qualified for need based aid I don't think. FWIW, she ended up at a very well regarded private university in California on scholarship. Last I heard from her she was grad school bound, so everything worked out. I do kind of wonder if her parents ever acknowledged that she was genuinely smart. I hope so. |
Actually, OP, I think the pp meant to say that "good" teachers don't think of their students or their parents as crazy. Only insecure and incompetent ones would even presume to have such a mindset. Which one are you? |
I do think that poster from the wifi thread has found a new home. Sitting back - this should be fun! |
Back away from the computer and go take your meds, crazy-pants. |
Do you acknowledge that there are actually unstable people in this world? And maybe some truly not nice people as well? And some of those people have kids. Kids who go to school. A good teacher cares about what is going on with a student outside of school. That means sometimes acknowledging that if a parent is acting unstable/abusive/aggressive/incredibly entitled towards folks at the school then the student is probably dealing with some pretty intense drama at home too. Putting total blinders on is not being a "good" teacher. A professional isn't going to call a parent crazy to their face or post a parent's name alongside an inappropriate note to the teacher on reddit or something, but they will absolutely *think* "crazy" about a person who is acting, well, crazy. That's part of being a human being and not a robot. If you want educators to never have opinions or feelings about interpersonal interactions with parents, then you're going to have to create an educational system that doesn't involve interpersonal interaction. BTW, I'm not sure altruism means what you think it does. At any rate, bringing it into a rant about teachers viewing certain parental behavior as crazy is a non-sequitur since altruism is about selfless acts, not about the actor having no feelings/opinions about others. |
NP here. Not a teacher, but a laid back parent. Give me a break!!! Every profession has crazy job stories!!! Why should teachers be different? I am actually liking this thread. As much as DCUM parents trash other parents, their DCs' teachers and school administrators, I think it is only fair for teachers to be able to share their stories too. |
+1 There is not a profession in this world that doesn't involve hilarious crazy stories. I am enjoying these as well. |
+1. Every profession involves interaction with nuts. I'm not a teacher but my jobs in various fields have confirmed for me that whack-jobs exist in every line of work. Venting here is better than exploding in the nut's face. IMO the angry poster defines "crazy, aggressive and abusive parent" and proves OP's point that these absolutely exist. The whack-job poster clearly has a huge sense of entitlement and thinks teachers exist to meekly serve his/her abusive demands. |
This has to be one of the dumbest ass things I have read. That is what a counselor and teacher is for...let you know about your abilities and opportunities...what the student and parent decide to do ABOUT THESE THINGS is their decision... But you put the choices out there.. What an idiot! |
* sending her brother to (sorry about that, missed a word in typing haste) And thanks for the validation PP. My folks weren't very knowledgeable about the world of college admissions or financial aid or scholarships. I (and they) were really grateful to a teacher I had who was a Brown grad who said "hey, you have a lot of options" and talked to me about what some of those options were. I really was surprised by the response from her parents. I hadn't run down the school they were targeting for her or anything, she just asked about colleges and we talked about her interests and some different options. I'd hope my kids have a counselor or teacher who says "hey have you looked at X school, they have a really great program in the field you're interested in" when the time comes. My principal supported me when the parents complained to him, so that was good as a young teacher because it could have gone the other way and been incredibly discouraging. |
+1. It is not a teacher's job to decide where a student applies and how much debt to take on. But, it is a teacher's job to give the student an accurate understanding of his or her talent, potential, and options. |
Altruism is about putting others first and in this case it means a teacher putting the education of their students first. Anyone who has the ability to put their students first would not have time to hang out in the teachers lounge discussing their students and their parents who they have backlisted as CRAZY.
If you consider every student and every parent CRAZY, who asks you a few simple questions then you have obviously chosen the wrong profession. Clearly, your level for tolerating life's minor annoyances is far too low for you to be successful at any profession and especially so for teaching. The truly great teachers are altruistic. They are not in it for the money, they work many more hours than they are paid creating dynamic comprehensive lessons, they ask probing questions to assess mastery, they read their students essays and problems, they mark them up and grade them fairly, and they develop teacher/student relationships on their own without being mindless slaves to the Teacher's Lounge Groupthink about students, parents, administrators. Altruistic teachers are kind and gentle, and they put their students first. Great teacher never allow themselves to become part of the cool-teacher clique. They never use uneducated uninformed pejorative terms in which they can't substantiate like crazy, insane, pita and helicoptering. Those are just the verbal expressions of selfish weak minded individuals who have clearly entered the wrong profession. If your teaching skills are being challenged it's not because your student's parents are crazy, it's because you are less than an effective teacher. If you are a less than an effective teacher then in all likelihood you enter this profession for the wrong reasons. You didn't enter the field of education teach because you have a true passion for the content matter in which you teach, you entered it to have your summers off, or to coach, to be able to pick and choose your teacher's pets, to be the smarty-pants in class again or to one day become an administrator and you can't wait to get out of the classroom. Take this weekend to think about the real reasons you entered the profession of teaching. If you come up with any other reasons besides having a burning passion to teach children everything you know about your subject and life in general, then you've chosen the wrong profession. If my advice to you makes me crazy in your opinion then you are a hopelessly flawed human being who has no chance of improvement or ever becoming a skillful teacher. |